Artificial intelligence and European integration in optimizing Ukraine`s pension system

Размещено на http://www.allbest.ru/

State University of Trade and Economics

Kyiv National Economic University named after Vadym Hetman

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND EUROPEAN INTEGRATION IN OPTIMIZING UKRAINE'S PENSION SYSTEM

V. Tokar, Doctor of Economic Sciences, Professor,

B. Tishkov, PhD in Economics, Associate Professor,

A. Lytvyniuk, PhD Student of the

Department of Information Systems in Economics

Annotation

artificial intelligence pension system

The article investigates the potential of incorporating artificial intelligence (AI) into Ukraine's pension system, with a focus on the country's efforts to align with European standards. As Ukraine faces demographic challenges, economic instability, and bureaucratic inefficiencies, the research explores how AI could enhance pension calculations, reduce administrative costs, and improve service delivery. The main goal is to evaluate the effective implementation of AI technologies within the EU regulatory framework, aligning with Ukraine's aspirations for EU integration. The study employs a SWOT analysis to assess the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats of implementing AI to optimize Ukraine's pension system.

The research identifies significant potential for AI to streamline Ukraine's pension system through automation and improved data management, which could lead to enhanced accuracy in pension distribution and operational efficiencies. However, the findings also highlight the critical need for substantial investments in technological infrastructure and the development of robust legal frameworks to support AI integration. The study acknowledges limitations, including the availability of current and comprehensive data, resistance to technological change among the population, and the high initial costs ass ociated with AI implementation.

The practical applications of this research are manifold; policymakers can leverage AI to make data-driven decisions that enhance the reliability and efficiency of the pension system. Additionally, the insights gained from this study could guide the development of policies that align with both national needs and European standards. This study contributes to the field by providing a context-specific examination of AI in the public sector, particularly within the framework of European integration. Unlike previous studies that have focused on the potential of AI, this article analyzes the role of AI in optimizing Ukraine's pension system within the context of its European integration development vector. Promising areas for future research include strategic public-private partnerships and hybrid methods for financing transformations in the Ukrainian pension system.

Keywords: artificial intelligence (AI), European integranon, pension system, social security system, Ukraine.

Анотація

B.В. Токар, д. е. н, професор, професор кафедри інженерії програмного забезпечення та кібербезпеки, Державний торговельно-економічний університет Б. О. Тішков, к. е. н., доцент, завідувач кафедри інформаційних систем в економіці, Київський національний економічний університет імені Вадима Гетьмана А. М. Литвинюк, аспірант кафедри інформаційних систем в економіці, Київський національний економічний університет імені Вадима Гетьмана

ШТУЧНИЙ ІНТЕЛЕКТ ТА ЄВРОПЕЙСЬКА ІНТЕГРАЦІЯ В ОПТИМІЗАЦІЇ ПЕНСІЙНОЇ СИСТЕМИ УКРАЇНИ

У статті досліджено потенціал впровадження штучного інтелекту (ШІ) в українську пенсійну систему через призму зусиль, спрямованих на наближення до європейських стандартів. Оскільки Україна стикається з демографічними викликами, економічною нестабільністю та бюрократичною неефективністю, у дослідженні визначено, як ШІ може покращити пенсійні розрахунки, зменшити адміністративні витрати та покращити надання послуг. Основна мета статті полягає в оцінюванні ефективності впровадження технологій штучного інтелекту в рамках нормативно -правової бази ЄС, що відповідає прагненню України до інтеграції в ЄС. У дослідженні використовується SWOT-аналіз для оцінки сильних і слабких сторін, можливостей і загроз впровадження штучного інтелекту для оптимізації пенсійної системи України.

Дослідження виявило значний потенціал ШІ для оптимізації пенсійної системи України завдяки автоматизації та покращенню управління даними, що може призвести до підвищення точності розподілу пенсій та операційної ефективності. Однак результати дослідження також підкреслюють гостру потребу в значних інвестиціях у технологічну інфраструктуру та розробку надійної нормативно-правової бази для підтримки інтеграції ШІ. Вказано, що викликами для імплементації ШІ в пенсійну систему України є: необхідність забезпечення актуальними та повними даними, опір технологічним змінам серед населення, а також високі початкові витрати, пов'язані з упровадженням ШІ.

Практичне значення дослідження полягає в можливості використання ШІ для прийняття рішень, які підвищують надійність та ефективність пенсійної системи. Крім того, висновки, отримані в результаті цього дослідження, можуть допомогти в розробці політики, яка відповідає як національним потребам, так і європейським стандартам. Це дослідження робить внесок у розвиток галузі, надаючи контекстно-специфічний аналіз штучного інтелекту в державному секторі, зокрема в рамках європейської інтеграції. На відміну від попередніх досліджень, які розглядають потенціал ШІ, ця стаття аналізує роль ШІ в оптимізації пенсійної системи України в контексті євроінтеграційного вектору розвитку. Перспективними напрямами майбутніх досліджень є стратегічні державно-приватні партнерства та гібридні методи фінансування перетворень у пенсійній системі України.

Ключові слова: штучний інтелект (ШІ), європейська інтеграція, пенсійна система, система соціального забезпечення, Україна.

General statement of the problem and its connection with important scientific or practical tasks

The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into government administration systems, such as pension systems, holds the promise of significant improvements in efficiency and effectiveness. This research focuses on optimizing Ukraine's pension system through AI and European integration, given the country's ongoing reforms and demographic challenges. Previous studies have demonstrated the potential of AI in enhancing social security systems across Europe, including improved administrative accuracy, policy planning, and beneficiary satisfaction.

Ukraine's pension system has faced challenges due to an aging population, economic instability, and bureaucratic inefficiencies. This study aims to investigate how AI technologies can be effectively implemented to improve pension calculations, reduce administrative costs, and enhance service delivery in Ukraine, while aligning these solutions with European Union guidelines and regulations, which is crucial for Ukraine's EU integration aspirations.

The research hypothesizes that AI, coupled with strategic European integration, can significantly optimize Ukraine's pension system. It contributes to the academic discourse on AI in public administration and provides actionable insights for policymakers. The study's novelty lies in its context-specific application of AI within the framework of European integration, offering a unique perspective on addressing systemic challenges in Ukraine' s pension system.

Analysis of recent studies and publications

The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and European principles into Ukraine's pension system represents a critical intersection of technology and policy that can potentially enhance the sustainability and efficiency of social security. The existing literature provides a comprehensive background for understanding the potential and challenges of optimizing Ukraine's pension framework through technological and policy innovations.

Borschevska and Zasnov highlight the absence of specific legal frameworks as a critical barrier to AI's full implementation in Ukraine's judiciary [1, p. 115-116], underscoring the need for tailored regulations across sectors, including the pension system. Lebid, Kiporenko, and Vovk outline the transformative potential of AI technologies in agriculture [2, p. 67-68] but overlook the technical and infrastructural readiness of Ukraine. Patsuriia's examination of AI in national security and defense illustrates the dual-edged nature of AI, necessitating robust, transparent, and inclusive legislative and regulatory frameworks [3, p. 75-76].

Havryliuk et al. provide a foundational economic-mathematical model to determine the optimal structural allocation of pension funds in Ukraine, offering a novel algorithm to forecast and enhance financial distributions [4, p. 227-228]. However, the practical application of their model remains theoretical. Martseniuk explores the operational aspects of the Pension Fund of Ukraine and private pension funds, aiming to align Ukraine's pension insurance practices with international standards [5, p. 202-203], but falls short in offering actionable strategies.

Zaiarnyi addresses the protection of individual rights in the context of AI utilization [6, p. 38-39], proposing specific improvements to protect information rights, while Kornieieva highlights the legal and human rights implications of AI deployment [7, p. 394], emphasizing the need for a robust legal framework. Li, Jiang, and Liu explore the practical applications of AI and wireless sensor networks in enhancing elderly care [8], though they overlook ethical and privacy concerns.

Zelenko examines the structural challenges and reform initiatives in EU and Ukrainian pension systems, underscoring the importance of pension system harmonization [9]. Parubets et al. propose enhanced state regulation, public-private partnerships, and digital infrastructure improvements to facilitate AI integration in Ukraine's economic frameworks [10, p. 266]. Saadeldin et al. delve into AI-driven financial models for pension fund management, highlighting the Artificial Bee Colony Optimization Approach [11, p. 119-120], while Kozak advocates for adopting global best practices and integrating AI to achieve a more robust and interconnected pension system in Ukraine [12, p. 120].

Vovchak, Halkiv, Kulinich, and Zhayvoronok provide a foundational analysis of Ukraine's pension challenges, focusing on financial imbalances in the Pension Fund of Ukraine and offering a critical perspective on revenue and expenditure dynamics [13, p. 373]. Zahidna and Sherementa discuss the three-tiered structure of the modern Ukrainian pension system [14, p. 22], emphasizing the necessity of addressing broader socio-economic issues and ensuring transparency. ParkhomenkoKutsevil examines the pension reforms implemented in select EU countries in response to demographic changes and economic pressures [15, p. 156-157], illustrating diverse approaches to maintaining pension system sustainability.

While the literature provides a solid foundation, significant gaps remain in the practical application of AI in the pension sector, the adaptation of European models to the Ukrainian context, and a balanced assessment of AI's benefits and limitations.

Formulation of the objectives of the article (task statement)

The objective is to provide a comprehensive understanding of the potential enhancements of Ukraine's pension system through AI and EU integration, and to outline strategies for effectively overcoming the obstacles.

Summary of the main research material

Table 1 summarizes strengths and weaknesses of Ukraine's pension system when considering the implementation of artificial intelligence (AI) to improve its efficiency. The analysis takes into account multiple factors such as the technological infrastructure available, socioeconomic conditions, and the existing regulatory framework. It evaluates how these different elements could impact the adoption of AI solutions to optimize the pension system's operations.

On the technological front, limited infrastructure especially in rural areas could hinder nationwide deployment of AI solutions. However, Ukraine's thriving IT sector with its innovative professionals and high mobile connectivity rates offer strengths to drive AI development and mobile access. Economically, the high costs of adopting AI pose a challenge given strained public budgets. But opportunities exist through international funding and partnerships with global tech firms. Socially, public skepticism around AI, data privacy concerns, and fears of job displacement need to be addressed through education and transparent communication.

The regulatory environment currently lacks robust laws governing ethical AI use and data protection - a notable weakness. But Ukraine's strong AI research community can provide expertise to shape appropriate regulations aligning with social needs. To capitalize on strengths and mitigate weaknesses, a multi-pronged strategy is crucial. This includes upgrading technological infrastructure, fostering public-private collaborations, enhancing AI education and training, and developing a comprehensive legal framework on AI governance.

Table 1

Optimizing Ukraine's pension system with AI: Strengths and Weaknesses

Source: elaborated by authors

Critically, AI pension solutions must be tailored to Ukraine's cultural and linguistic context for broader acceptance. Customizing the technology is key to ensuring its effectiveness in streamlining pension management accessibly nationwide. While significant challenges exist, Ukraine's existing strengths provide a solid foundation to build upon through strategic investments in technology, robust policies, and stakeholder engagement. Overcoming the obstacles can unlock AI's potential in enhancing the efficiency and equity of Ukraine's pension services.

Table 2 outlines the potential opportunities and threats linked with the integration of AI for enhancing Ukraine's pension system.

Table 2

Optimizing Ukraine's pension system with AI: Opportunities and Threats

Source: elaborated by authors

The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) in Ukraine's pension system offers both promising opportunities and potential challenges. On the positive side, AI can significantly reduce fraud by detecting patterns of fraudulent activities, ensuring fair distribution of pensions. Its precision in calculations can minimize errors, improving the system's reliability. AI can also automate routine tasks, leading to faster service and higher user satisfaction, while lowering operational costs through reduced manual processing. Furthermore, AI enables personalized pension plans tailored to individual circumstances, as well as enhanced data analysis for better investment strategies and resource allocation. Predictive modeling and improved reporting capabilities can aid in long-term planning and ensure system sustainability. AI can also support decision-making processes by providing valuable insights to policymakers.

However, the implementation of AI in the pension system is not without risks. Privacy concerns arise from the increased collection and processing of personal data, requiring robust security measures. Job displacement due to automation may have social and economic repercussions. Over-reliance on AI systems can create vulnerabilities, and the initial investment costs can be prohibitive. Ethical concerns, such as perpetuating biases, and potential data mismanagement must be addressed. Additionally, AI systems may be targets for cyberattacks, compromising sensitive pension data. Legal challenges related to AI usage and resistance to change can also hinder effective integration. By carefully considering these opportunities and threats, Ukraine can leverage AI to enhance its pension system's efficiency, accuracy, and responsiveness while mitigating potential risks through appropriate strategies and safeguards.

Table 3 provides a structured overview of the possible benefits and drawbacks of integrating Ukraine's pension system with the European Union, emphasizing the complex balance between adopting new practices and adapting to a broad and diverse regulatory environment.

The analysis of integrating Ukraine's pension system with the European Union reveals both promising opportunities and formidable challenges. On one hand, European integration could provide significant benefits to Ukraine's pension system. There is the potential for increased funding from EU sources allocated to bolstering social systems across member states. Additionally, Ukraine could adopt proven best practices from successful pension models already implemented by EU countries, leading to improved governance and efficiency. Worker mobility would also increase, allowing labor to move freely across borders while maintaining pension rights.

Table 3

Opportunities and Challenges of European Integration for Ukraine's Pension System

Source: elaborated by authors

However, these opportunities are counterbalanced by considerable obstacles.

Bringing Ukraine's pension system into compliance with EU standards would require costly reforms across legal, financial, and administrative domains before any benefits could be realized. Implementing new technology platforms needed to modernize the system also represents a major investment of resources and training. Perhaps most daunting is the challenge of harmonizing Ukraine's unique pension system with the diverse systems already in place across EU member states.

The juxtaposition of opportunities and challenges demonstrates the precarious balance Ukraine must strike as it pursues EU integration of its pension system. While the potential advantages include enhanced funding, improved operations, and better mobility for workers, the risks involve significant financial costs, technological hurdles, and complex systemic harmonization. Ultimately, Ukraine must carefully weigh how to best leverage the opportunities while mitigating the formidable challenges. A prudent, phased approach to integration and compliance may be required to realize the rewards without being overwhelmed by the complexities involved.

Conclusions and prospects for further research in this area

The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into Ukraine's pension system offers significant value - added benefits. AI can automate processes, reduce administrative burdens, minimize errors, and facilitate personalized pension planning tailored to individuals' financial situations. This enhances user satisfaction and trust. AI is also valuable for detecting fraud and ensuring fair pension distribution.

In terms of policy implications, investments are needed in technological infrastructure, especially in rural areas, to enable widespread AI deployment. The government must foster an environment supportive of digitization and AI adoption while addressing data privacy concerns and regulatory gaps around data protection and ethical AI use to build public and institutional trust. Policy makers should explore international funding and partnerships with tech firms to offset high initial integration costs and enhance Ukraine's technological capabilities.

While AI integration offers clear benefits for efficiency, accuracy, and service personalization, challenges must be carefully managed. These include infrastructure deficits, regulatory gaps, and societal skepticism towards new technologies. A strategic, multi-pronged approach involving infrastructure upgrades, legal reforms, and public-private partnerships can maximize AI's benefits while minimizing risks. Ukraine must remain vigilant in monitoring technological changes and proactively adapting strategies to realize AI's full transformative potential for its pension system.

Future research should empirically investigate the long-term impacts of AI on pension system efficiency and fairness. Studies on the socio-economic impacts like job displacement are also needed. Additionally, more focused research is required on developing culturally and linguistically tailored AI systems for Ukraine's diverse population to ensure inclusivity and effectiveness.

Literature

1. Борщевська О. М., Заснов І. О. (2023). Правові підстави та перспективи використання штучного інтелекту в судочинстві України. Правова держава, Вип. 50, с. 106-119. URL: https://doi.org/10.18524/2411-2054.2023.50.280278 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

2. Лебідь, О. В., Кіпоренко, С. С., Вовк, В. Ю. (2023). Використання технологій штучного інтелекту в сільському господарстві: європейський досвід та застосування в Україні. Електронне моделювання, Т. 45. № 3, c. 57-71. URL: https://doi.org/10.15407/emodel.45.03.057 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

3. Пацурія Н. (2023). Упровадження технологій штучного інтелекту в забезпечення національної безпеки та обороноздатності України: правові проблеми і перспективи повоєнного періоду. Теорія і практика інтелектуальної власності, Вип. 3, с. 68-78. URL: https://doi.org/10.33731/32023.282185 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

4. Havryliuk, V., Rudyk, V., Melnyk, L., Kondratska, N., Burdeniuk, S. (2022). Optimization Model of Structural Allocation of Financial Resources in the Pension System of Ukraine. Review of Economics and Finance, vol. 20, pp. 216-228. URL: https://refpress.org/ref-vol20-a26/ (date of access: 10.02.2024).

5. Martseniuk, O. (2022). Current state and directions of integration of Ukraine's pension system into the European and world pension system. Global trends and prospects of socio-economic development of Ukraine, pp. 177-204. URL: https://doi.org/10.30525/978-9934-26-193-0-6 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

6. Заярний, О. (2022). До питання удосконалення способів захисту інформаційних прав фізичних осіб у відносинах, пов'язаних із застосуванням технологій штучного інтелекту. Вісник Київського національного університету імені Тараса Шевченка, Вип. 1 (120), с. 36-39. URL: https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2022/L120-7 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

7. Корнєєва, С. Р. (2021). Вплив застосування технологій штучного інтелекту на реалізацію та захист прав людини. Аналітично -порівняльне правознавство, № 4, с. 392-394. URL: https://doi.org/10.24144/2788-6018.2021.04.69 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

8. Li, L., Jiang, L., Liu, Z. (2021). Optimization Research of Artificial Intelligence and Wireless Sensor Networks in Smart Pension. Hindawi Scientific Programming, vol. 2021, article ID 5421668, 7 pages. URL: https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/5421668 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

9. Zelenko, V. (2021). Introduction of the accumulative component into the pension system of Ukraine: assessing of European practices. Przeglqd Europejski, vol. 2020, no. 3, pp. 161-176. URL: https://doi.org/10.31338/1641-2478pe.3.20.10 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

10. Parubets, O., Panchenko, O., Bazlinska, O., Sugonyako, D. (2019). Research on the Use of the Artificial Intelligence by Management of the Economic System of the State. Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Strategies, Models and Technologies of Economic Systems Management (SMTESM 2019). Advances in Economics, Business and Management Research, vol. 95, pp. 262 -266. URL: https://doi.org/10.2991/smtesm-19.2019.51 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

11. Saadeldin, S., Zaher, H., Ragaa, N., Sayed, H. (2021). Artificial Intelligence Approach to Secure Pension Fund. Journal of University of Shanghai for Science and Technology, vol. 23, issue 7, pp. 110-120. URL: https://jusst.org/wpcontent/uploads/2021/06/Artificial-Intelligence-Approach-to-Secure-PensionFund.pdf (date of access: 10.02.2024).

12. Козак, Т. М. (2021). Напрями інтеграції системи пенсійного забезпечення України до європейської та світової пенсійної системи. Інвестиції: практика та досвід, № 4, с. 116-121. URL: https://doi.org/10.32702/2306-6814.2021.4.116 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

13. Вовчак, О. Д., Гальків, Л. І., Кулініч, Т. В., Жайворонок, І. Р. (2020). Формування фінансово стабільної пенсійної системи в Україні: виклики, передумови, критерії, заходи. Financial and Credit Activity Problems of Theory and Practice, Вип. 4 (35), с. 367-373. URL: https://doi.org/10.18371/fcaptp.v4i35.222411 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

14. Західна О.Р., Шеремета Л.М. (2022). Аналіз поточного стану пенсійного забезпечення в Україні. Young Scientist. № 5 (105), с. 17-23. URL: https://doi.org/10.32839/2304-5809/2022-5-105-4 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

15. Пархоменко-Куцевіл, О.І. (2023). Реформування системи пенсійного забезпечення: європейські практики та досвід для України. Наукові перспективи, № 1 (31), с. 149-159. URL: https://doi.org/10.52058/2708-7530-20231(31)-149-159 (date of access: 10.02.2024).

References

1. Borschevska, O. M., Zasnov, I. O. (2023), “Legal basis and prospects of the use of artificial intelligence in the judicial system of Ukraine ”, Constitutional State, vol. 50, pp. 106-119. DOI: https://doi.org/10.18524/2411-2054.2023.50.280278.

2. Lebid, O. V., Kiporenko, S. S., Vovk, V. Yu. (2023), “Use of artificial intelligence technologies in agriculture: European experience and application in Ukraine”, Electronic modeling, vol. 45, no 3, pp. 51-71. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15407/emodel.45.03.057.

3. Patsuriia, N. (2023), “Implementation of Artificial Intelligence Technologies for Ensuring National Security and Defense Capability of Ukraine: Legal Issues and Prospects for the Post-War Period”, Theory and Practice of Intellectual Property, vol. 3, pp. 68-78. DOI: https://doi.org/10.33731/32023.282185.

4. Havryliuk, V., Rudyk, V., Melnyk, L., Kondratska, N., Burdeniuk, S. (2022), “Optimization Model of Structural Allocation of Financial Resources in the Pension System of Ukraine”, Review of Economics and Finance, vol. 20, pp. 216228, available at: https://refpress.org/ref-vol20-a26/ (Accessed 10.02.2024).

5. Martseniuk, O. (2022), “Current state and directions of integration of Ukraine's pension system into the European and world pension system”, Global trends and prospects of socio-economic development of Ukraine, pp. 177-204. DOI: https://doi.org/10.30525/978-9934-26-193-0-6.

6. Zaiarnyi, O. (2022), “Towards the issue on improving the protection of information rights of individuals in relations connected with the use of artificial intelligence technologies”, Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv. Legal Studies, vol. 1 (120), pp. 36-39. DOI: https://doi.org/10.17721/1728-2195/2022/1.120-7.

7. Kornieieva S. (2021), “The impact of the use of artificial intelligence technologies on the implementation and protection of human rights”, Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence, vol. 4, pp. 392-394. DOI: https://doi.org/10.24144/27886018.2021.04.69.

8. Li, L., Jiang, L., Liu, Z. (2021), “Optimization Research of Artificial Intelligence and Wireless Sensor Networks in Smart Pension”, Hindawi Scientific Programming, vol. 2021, article ID 5421668, 7 pages. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/5421668.

9. Zelenko, V. (2021), “Introduction of the accumulative component into the pension system of Ukraine: assessing of European practices”, Przeglqd Europejski, vol. 2020, no. 3, pp. 161-176. DOI: https://doi.org/10.31338/1641-2478pe.3.20.10.

10. Parubets, O., Panchenko, O., Bazlinska, O., Sugonyako, D. (2019), “Research on the Use of the Artificial Intelligence by Management of the Economic System of the State”, Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Strategies, Models and Technologies of Economic Systems Management (SMTESM 2019). Advances in Economics, Business and Management Research, vol. 95, pp. 262-266. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2991/smtesm-19.2019.51.

11. Saadeldin, S., Zaher, H., Ragaa, N., Sayed, H. (2021), “Artificial Intelligence Approach to Secure Pension Fund”, Journal of University of Shanghai for Science and Technology, vol. 23, issue 7, pp. 110-120, available at: https://jusst.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Artificial-Intelligence-Approach-toSecure-Pension-Fund.pdf (Accessed 10.02.2024).

12. Kozak, T. (2021), “Integration directions of Ukraine's pension system into European and world pension system”, Investytsiyi: praktyka ta dosvid, vol. 4, pp. 116-121. DOI: https://doi.org/10.32702/2306-6814.202E4.116.

13. Vovchak, O., Halkiv, L., Kulinich, T., Zhayvoronok, I. (2020), “Formation of financially stable pension system in Ukraine: challenges, prerequisites, criteria, measures”, Financial and Credit Activity Problems of Theory and Practice, vol. 4 (35), pp. 367-373. DOI: https://doi.org/10.18371/fcaptp.v4i35.222411.

14. Zahidna, O., Sherementa, L. (2022), “Analysis of the current state of pension support in Ukraine”, Young Scientist, vol. 5 (105), pp. 17-23. DOI: https://doi.org/10.32839/2304-5809/2022-5-105-4.

15. Parkhomenko-Kutsevil, O. I. (2023), “Reforming the pension system: European practices and experience for Ukraine”, Scientific Perspectives, vol. 1 (31), pp. 149-159. DOI: https://doi.org/10.52058/2708-7530-2023-1(31)-149-159.

Размещено на Allbest.ru