Alternative Splicing Regulation in Polypedilum vanderplanki Under Dehydration-rehydration Cycle
Investigation of genes involved in the processes of ensuring resistance to desiccation in Polypedilum vanderplanki. Comparison of survival, expression and splicing between knockdown and wild-type cells. Analysis of the dehydration-rehydration cycle.
Рубрика | Медицина |
Вид | дипломная работа |
Язык | английский |
Дата добавления | 17.08.2020 |
Размер файла | 3,1 M |
Отправить свою хорошую работу в базу знаний просто. Используйте форму, расположенную ниже
Студенты, аспиранты, молодые ученые, использующие базу знаний в своей учебе и работе, будут вам очень благодарны.
Размещено на http://allbest.ru
FEDERAL STATE AUTONOMOUS EDUCATIONAL INSITUTION FOR HIGHER PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION NATIONAL RESEARCH UNIVERSITY
«HIGHER SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS»
Faculty of Computer Science
Qualification paper - Master of Science Dissertation
Alternative Splicing Regulation in Polypedilum vanderplanki Under Dehydration-rehydration Cycle
(Регуляция Альтернативного сплайсинга у Polypedilum vanderplanki в течении цикла дегидратации-регидратации)
Field of study 01.04.02 «Applied Mathematics and Informatics»
Program: Data Analysis in Biology and Medicine
Student: A.A. Tagmazian
Supervisor: PhD. P.V Mazin
Moscow, 2020
Table of contents
Introduction
1. Literature review
1.1 Polypedilum vanderplanki
1.2 Mechanism of splicing
1.3 Alternative splicing
1.4 Regulation of alternative splicing
1.5 Alternative splicing in P. Vanderplanki
2. Materials and methods
2.1 Data
2.2 Methods
3. Results and Discussion
3.1 Differential splicing analysis
3.2 Splicing sites' strength
3.3 Intron length distribution
3.4 Motif analysis
Conclusion
References
Supplementary
Introduction
Actuality. The study of the adaptive abilities of animals to extreme environmental conditions and the molecular processes underlying them is a significant direction in modern science. One of these skills is the ability of some organisms to fall into a state of anhydrobiosis. When the organism loses up to 99% of the moisture in the body due to drying out and at the same time be able to return to a normal state and produce prolific offspring. Polypedilum vanderplanki is one of the unique animal world representatives, capable of entering reversible anhydrobiosis at the larval stage. The Polypedilum vanderplanki is interesting not only from the theoretical side but also from practical. The understanding of the desiccation process and adaptation to it on a molecular level could be used in the future in agriculture or medicine. For example in biomaterials storage, it could replace the liquid nitrogen and reduce economic costs in this area. A detailed study of alternative splicing and its regulation at different stages of the dehydration-rehydration cycle could explain how P. vanderplanki manages its transcription and translation during anhydrobiosis and what regulations pathways are involved in it.
Goal. The goal of this research is to explore the regulation of alternative splicing and its role under dehydration-rehydration cycle in Polypedilum vanderplanki larva.
Objectives. To achieve this goal, the following objectives were set:
1) Consideration of scientific literature on this topic.
2) Alignment of reads to the reference genome, counting reads based on alignment and genes annotation, building the functional annotation for genes.
3) Finding of AS events with statistically significant changes of inclusion ratio between fully hydrated state and different stages of dehydration-rehydration cycle.
4) Comparison of the splicing sites' strength and introns' length distribution of constitutive and alternatives segments.
5) Search for potential alternative splicing regulators using differential splicing and expression analysis, GO enrichment and motif enrichment analysis.
Object of study. The object of current research is the Polypedilum vanderplanki larvae on different stages of the dehydration-rehydration cycle.
Subject of study. The subject of this research is alternative splicing regulation pathways, their influence on splicing and role under anhydrobiosis in Polypedilum vanderplanki larva.
General research plan. The master's thesis was performed in stages, shown in Figure 1.1.
Figure 1.1. General research plan
The structure of work. The structure of the thesis is the following. The first chapter is introduction, the second presents the review of relevant literature, third describes the data and methods which were used in the research. The 4th section reports about obtained results and what they could mean within the issue. There are the main results and the following suggestions in the 5th section. Also, there are some additional materials in `Supplementary'.
1. Literature review
1.1 Polypedilum vanderplanki
Polypedilum vanderplanki or the sleeping chironomid is a dipteran in the family Chironomidae (non-biting midges). Northern Nigeria and Uganda are the main habitats of the species. The first time it was discovered by Dr. F. L. Vanderplank, who noticed that larvae of the species can survive in dried mud. The main characteristics of chironomids and effects of high temperature on larvae first time were described by H. E. Hinton in 1951. [19]
Figure 2.1. Schematic illustration of Polypedilum vanderplanki life cycle, included 5 stages of anhydrobiosis used in the research. Figure (with modification) was taken from [21, 51].
Anhydrobiosis is the most studied form of cryptobiosis Cryptobiosis - a physiological state in which metabolic activity is reduced to an undetectable level without disappearing altogether entered in response to adverse environmental conditions. and occurs in situations of extreme desiccation. (from Greek `life without water') It was observed in many microorganisms, plant seeds, some plants, invertebrate animals and at least one insect -- Polypedilum vanderplanki.[10, 52, 56]
However, the sleeping chironomid exhibits desiccation tolerance only on the larvae stage. In anhydrobiotic condition larvae can live more than 17 years and be exposed to temporary high (103є) or low (-190є) temperatures, radiation (7000 Gy) or immersing into 100% ethanol. [16, 57]
The process of desiccation takes around 48 hours, while rehydration starts in 30 minutes after contact with liquid water and continues up to 24 hours. (Figure 2.1) During these short periods, the organism has to go through complicated biochemical processes determining further survival of larva. [7, 19]
Trehalose, hemolymphatic disaccharide of insects, plays the key role in successful desiccation. It is the well-known fact that trehalose works as a compatible solute in an organism with desiccation tolerance, such as nematodes, tardigrades and Artemia cysts. Due to chemico-physical characteristics, this disaccharide can be accumulated in a high quantity without harm to organisms, replacing water and protecting biomolecules from degradation. [13] There are 3 theories describing the trehalose protection mechanism. The first theory suggests that trehalose forms hydrogen bonds inside and outside the bilipid membrane to maintain its integrity instead of water. The second hypothesis is based on the fact that dehydration causes the formation of `trehalose glass', which fills the space originally occupied by water, and limits the physical and chemical interactions between biomolecules and their mobility, thereby preventing their damage. The third is based on the assumption that trehalose retains a thin layer of water around the proteins, which prevents their denaturation during drying [8, 9, 48]. In the sleeping chironomid trehalose synthesis grows rapidly when the water content in the organism decreases to 75%. Presumably, the increased osmotic pressure and changes of ionic concentration are the factors inducing the trehalose synthesis. [13, 58]
In addition to trehalose, Late Embryo Abundant (LEA) proteins are also involved in the protection of cells from damage during desiccation. Initially, they have been found in plant seed and shown its accumulation in response to dehydration and changes in ion concentration. The protein changes its tertiary structure from random to coiled-helix structure during desiccation and, hypothetically, binds with intracellular ions or with each other for cell protection.[24] gene splicing cell polypedilum
Moreover, Heat shock proteins (HSPs) also work as protein protectors during desiccation in P. vanderplanki. HSP belongs to the chaperones family and produced in the cell under stress environments such as extreme temperature or UV light.[54] In the sleeping chironomid several HSPs increased their expression during dehydration were found (Pv-hsp90, Pv-hsp70, Pv-hsc70, Pv-hsp60). Thus, during the dehydration-rehydration cycle in P. vanderplanki some heat shock proteins protect proteins from denaturation and refold denatured proteins. [15]
Along with trehalose, LEA and HSPs, antioxidants, small redox proteins, protein-repair methyltransferases, hemoglobins, and aquaporins also participate in the successful course of anhydrobiosis. [16]
Polypedilum vanderplanki continues to be one of the favorite model organisms to study the anhydrobiosis process. Scientists keep exploring the genome, transcriptome, and proteome of the sleeping chironomid, looking for changes between stages of the dehydration-rehydration cycle and regulatory pathways brought to them [15, 18, 39].
1.2 Mechanism of splicing
Since 1977 science world considers that eukaryotic genes contain a lot of interruptions and mRNA is not just a copy of DNA as an indisputable fact. They consist of protein-coding regions (exons) and non-coding regions (introns). Around 15 years later Phillip Allen Sharp and Richard J. Roberts discovered the RNA splicing, the process of introns removing and transformation of pre-mRNA into mRNA.[1, 6, 49] However, not only protein-coding genes go through RNA processing steps. The majority of long non-coding RNA also undergo splicing. [29]
The key roles in the RNA splicing process play splicing sites - short conserved sequences at intron ends. Spliceosome, a complex molecular machine consisting of multiple RNAs and protein, recognizes and bind splicing sites on newly synthesized RNA. There are three splice sites in an intron. First, donor 5' splice site (5'SS), it locates close to the 5' end of the intron and contains conservative dinucleotide - GU. Second, acceptor 3' splice site (3'SS) places near the 3' end of the intron and is represented by almost invariant dinucleotide - AG. Upstream of 3' SS is a region with high C and U content, polypyrimidine tract. Third, around 50 nucleotides upstream from the acceptor site lie the branchpoint (BP), which included an adenine nucleotide. (Figure 2.2)[50]
Figure 2.2. Logos of splice sites (a) 5' splice site (b) branch point site (c) 3' splice site. [30]
From the chemical side of the question, splicing is two sequential phosphoryl-transfer reactions (transesterification). During first, branching, 2' hydroxyl of adenosine in the branchpoint attacks a phosphate at 5' SS, thereby splitting the upstream exon and 5' end of the intron and forming an intermediate stage with `lariat'. In the second reaction, exon ligation, the new formed 3' hydroxyl group on 5' end attacks phosphate at 3' SS to merge the exons and remove the intron. (Figure 2.3) However, easy on the first glance the process becomes more complicated if taking into account the spliceosomal complex.[20]
Figure 2.3. The schematic view of the splicing process. (top) Two sequential phosphoryl-transfer reactions[14] (bottom) Spliceosome assembly and transformation complex, where U1,U2,U4,U5 and U6 are the spliceosomal small nuclear ribonucleoproteins. [30] Abbreviation: SS, splice site.
A spliceosome is a ribonucleoprotein enzyme, which catalyzed the splicing reaction. It is composed of snRNAs and over 70 associated proteins. Major spliceosome contains 5 spliceosome subunits: U1, U2, U4, U5, and U6. They in combination with proteins form complexes in different conformations and generate an active enzyme site. (Figure 2.3)
The first spliceosome complex ('A') forms when U1 and U2 bind with 5' splice site and branch point, respectively. Three subunits, U4, U5, and U6, generate triple snRNP, bind with the complex A and transform it into the precatalytic spliceosome ('B'). However, complex B is not stable and active, thus ATPases Prp28 and Brr2 dissociate U1 and U4 snRNA, respectively. A new Bact complex contains U2, U6, and U5 catalyze the first phosphoryl-transfer reaction to form the C complex. The ATPase Prp16 remodels spliceosome again and prepares it for the `intron ligation' reaction. The U5 subunit aligns flanking exons and finally, the intron is ligated, flanking exons merge and mRNA releases. [14, 59]
There are two potential mechanisms of splice site recognition called intron and exon definition. (Figure 2.4) The first is based on intron identification and places the splicing basal machinery across introns. The length of the intron, in this case, should be quite small (200-250 nt). This way could be more ancient and spread in organisms with short introns, for example, yeast. In higher metazoa, particularly vertebrates, the opposite situation happens. There are short exons (~300 nt) and long introns. Thus exon definition is more logical and the basal splicing machinery is placed across exons. However, the later spliceosome actions are aimed at the intron region.[45, 60]
Figure 2.4. Schematic illustration of intron and exon definition processes, where U1 and U2 are the spliceosomal small nuclear ribonucleoproteins and ss - splice site.[5]
1.3 Alternative splicing
Same RNA could be spliced in different ways. It could create multiple variants of mRNA from one gene using combinations of exons.
This mechanism is called alternative splicing. It helps the cell not only keep protein diversity but either control gene expression, reply to stressful environmental and pathological cellular conditions.
Currently, there are 4 main types of alternative splicing described in the literature. (Figure 2.5) [47]
1) Cassette exon is the most frequently occurring, around ? of all alternative splicing events. Exon could be included or excluded from the transcript.
2) Intron retention. Intron will be included in the transcript.
3) Alternative 5' splice site. Spliceosome binds with an alternative donor site, thus upstream exon becomes shorter or longer.
4) Alternative 3' splice site. The alternative acceptor site will be used and the 3' end of downstream exon will be changed.
Figure 2.5. Types of alternative splicing. Modified [31]
1.4 Regulation of alternative splicing
Alternative splicing depends on splice sites' selection by spliceosome. There are two models explaining how the transcriptional environment can affect this choice.
The `recruitment model' suggests that alternative splicing is regulated by the direct or indirect recruitment of trans-elements to pre-mRNA. The `kinetic model' proposes that the rate of RNAPII elongation affects the process of splice sites' selection. [12]
The RNA polymerase II speed. According to the kinetic model, the changes in the rate of RNAPII complexes can affect alternative splicing regulation. Under slow transcription spliceosomes have enough time to assemble on weak splice sites that results in increased inclusion of cassette exons. Accordingly, faster elongation results in a greater number of splice sites available simultaneously, that allow spliceosome to select stronger one.
Faster elongation was shown to be associated with increased exons skipping [36]. Also, the speed of transcription influence on the formation of pre-mRNA secondary structure and can block or open the access to cis-regulation elements. [12]
RNA-Protein Interaction. Cis- and Trans-acting elements play key roles in alternative splicing regulation. Splicing cis-regulatory elements (CREs) are the regions of pre-mRNA that either enhance or suppress the splicing. We can figure out four types of splicing CREs: exonic splicing enhancers (ESEs), intronic splicing enhancers (ISEs), exonic splicing silencers (ESSs) and intronic splicing silencers (ISSs) (Figure 2.6).
Enhancers could be bound by proteins that help the spliceosome in the exon and intron definition process. Silencers interact with splicing factors that prevent interaction between the spliceosome complex and the exon splice sites.
These two mechanisms balance each other. ESEs and ISEs are spread around constitutive exons, while ISSs and ESSs could be involved in alternative splicing control. [55]
Figure 2.6.Cis-acting elements' location and regulatory action on exon splicing. SR is a serine/arginine-rich protein promoted the splice sites recognition by binding with exonic splicing enhancers (ESEs) or intronic splicing enhancers (ISEs). hnRNP is heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoproteins which play the role of repressor, binding with exonic splicing silencers (ESSs) or intronic splicing silencers (ISSs).[30]
However, CREs work in pairs with Trans-acting elements, splicing factors. In general, all SFs could be divided into three groups [30].
1) SR proteins, a family of nuclear factors, play an important role in splicing. The family name was given because of the serine/arginine-rich protein domain. Moreover, it contains one or more RNA recognition motif regions (RRM). (Figure 2.6, Figure 2.7(I)) The involvement of SR proteins in splicing begins already during RNA synthesis. It binds with the RNA polymerase II and then moves on pre-mRNA. [34] Where the transcription factors work in two connected directions. First, it can stimulate the spliceosome complex formation. Step by step it helps U1, U2AF, U2, and triple snRNPs recruiting and binding with correct sites. Second, SR proteins participate in alternative splice site selection. It could be either a repressor or an activator, but more often it interacts with ESEs or ISEs and promotes spliceosome assembly. (Figure 2.7(II)) Further, the splicing factor participates in a post-splicing activity. [45]
Figure 2.7. Trans-acting elements. (I) Examples of domain architectures of SR proteins. (II) The possible ways of alternative splicing regulation by SR proteins. Modified [45].(III) Examples of domain architectures of hnRNP. (IV) The possible ways of alternative splicing regulation by hnRNP.[35]Abbreviations: SC35/ SF2/ASF/SR - serine/arginine-rich protein; U1/U2 - the spliceosomal small nuclear ribonucleoproteins; ss - splice site; BS - branch splice site; PPT - polypyrimidine tract; ESE - exonic splicing enhancers; hnRNP - heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoproteins; RRM - RNA recognition motif; RS - serine/arginine-rich domain; RGG - Arg-Gly-Gly tripeptides; KH - K homology domain.
2) The heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoproteins (hnRNP) are complexes of RNA and proteins. It contains RNA recognition motif region (RRM) or K homology (KH) domain, repeats of Arg-Gly-Gly tripeptides (RGG box) and glycine-rich, acidic or proline-rich domains. (Figure 2.7(III)) It is involved in various processes, but the most interesting is its function in splicing. Using RRM or KH domains hnRNPs bind with a specific site, frequently ESSs or ISSs. It is well known as a repressor, but sometimes it can play the role of activator.
Further hnRNPs proteins participate in splicing in different ways. (Figure 2.7(IV)) Firstly, it blocks access of spliceosome components to the specific binding sites either by neighborhood site interaction (Figure 2.7(IV.A)) or by the propagation of hnRNP along the pre-mRNA and creation zone of local repression (Figure 2.7(IV.B)).
Second, the splicing factor could prevent interaction between spliceosome units during exon or intron definition. (Figure 2.7(IV.C)) Third, it can flank the exon, bind with each other and create a stem-loop regulated alternative splice site selection or constitutive splicing. (Figure 2.7(IV.D)) [35]
3) Splicing is a tissue-specific process, so one gene can produce different isoforms depending on a tissue. Consequently, there are tissue-specific RNA-binding proteins for the regulation of the process. For example, Nova and PTB/hnRNPI in neurons, members of the Rbfox family or CELF family. In some cases, they can be repressors or activators, sometimes only one of them. [30]
RNA-RNA interaction. RNA-RNA base pairing is the one more powerful mechanism of splicing regulation. It also can engage the cis- and trans-elements, which would affect pre-mRNA processing.
Secondary structure. The formation of secondary structures could regulate the accessibility of splicing factors or spliceosomes to splicing sites or other regulation motives. It can occur as hair-pin or as RNA duplex and plays the role either enhancer or silencer. (Figure 2.8)[30]
The bright example of RNA-RNA interaction regulation of splicing is the Drosophila DSCAM gene. (Figure 2.8) Dscam is an immunoglobulin (Ig) superfamily protein. It contains a set of alternative mutually exclusive 6th exons, which inclusion generates more than 30.000 mRNA isoforms.
Figure 2.8. Alternative splicing regulation by RNA-RNA interaction. (top) The hairpin formation can either block the access to splicing factor binding motif or recruit proteins that recognize specific RNA structures and act as splicing enhancers or repressors. Green box is an intronic splicing enhancer, red box is an intronic splicing silencer. [12] (bottom) Illustration of Drosophila DSCAM gene-splicing regulation by the formation of the duplex. Orange boxes - alternative mutually exclusive 6th exons, yellow circles - HRP36, protein blocking the splicing, green circle - SR, protein promoting the splicing.[12, 30]
There is conservative site downstream exon 5 and complementary to it conserved sites upstream of each alternative 6th exon. The base pairing between the sites will define which of the 6th exon variations will be included in the transcript.[37]
ncRNA regulation. Except the snoRNA from spliceosome other non-coding RNA also can bind with pre-mRNA and participate in alternative splicing regulation. It works as a repressor, binding with splice sites or splicing enhancers and prevents the connection with the corresponding splicing machinery. Either its connection with splicing silencers can promote exon inclusion. Small RNA even can recruit the splicing factor. (Figure 2.9(I)) [23]
An excellent example of ncRNA splicing regulation is the role of snoRNA HBII-52 in Prader-Willi syndrome development. (Figure 2.9(II))
Figure 2.9. The ncRNA regulation of alternative splicing. (I) The alternative splicing regulatory pathways binding with short RNAs. (A and B) The interaction of U1 and U2 spliceosome subunits with donor and acceptor splice sites, respectively. (C-F) ncRNA blocks the acceptor, donor splice sites, splicing enhancer or silencers, respectively. (G) Small RNA recruits splicing activator or repressor protein to the exon. (II) Splicing regulation of serotonin receptor 5-HT2C by snoRNA HBII-52. (A) Exons of serotonin receptor 5-HT2C. (B) HBII-52 interaction with Vb exon creates three different transcripts. (C ) The first transcript without Vb exon will not be translated. The second mRNA contains edited Vb exon and produces the weak receptor with amino acid substitutions. While the inclusion of Vb exon will generate a strong serotonin receptor. [23]
The probable cause of its occurrence is the loss of RNA expression of the snoRNA set including HBII-52. It contains a conservative region complementary to alternative Vb exon in the serotonin receptor 5-HT2C pre-mRNA. Vb exon has splicing silences motifs and without the interaction with ncRNA most probably will not be included in a transcript. This mRNA will generate a non-functional receptor. Consequently, the loss of HBII-52 expression can lead to decreasing in receptor functionality and the following disorders. [27]
1.5 Alternative splicing in P. Vanderplanki
Currently, only a few research describe alternative splicing in P. Vanderplanki during anhydrobiosis. There mentioned alternative splicing events in genes coding heat shock factor (HSF) and trehalose-6-phosphate synthase (PvTps a and PvTps b). [39, 43] As far as splicing and its regulation have a direct influence on genes' transcription and translation, particularly, involved in dehydration-rehydration processes, the multilateral study of alternative splicing regulation is relevant and requires more detailed consideration.
2. Materials and methods
2.1 Data
The necessary data to the study were kindly provided and given by O. Gusev research team from Kazan Federal University and include itself next files:
1) The new assembly of Polypedilum vanderplanki genome (120 Mbp).
2) Genome annotation in the GFF3 format.
3) The RNA-seq single-end unstranded dataset collected from the pull of Polypedilum vanderplanki larvae on five stages of the dehydration-rehydration cycle. (Figure 2.1) There were two replicates by each stage.
PvD0 - samples of larvae in normal condition, before dehydration
PvD24 - samples after 24 hours of desiccation
PvD48 - samples after 48 hours of desiccation
PvR3 - samples after 3 hours of rehydration
PvR24 - samples after 24 hours of rehydration
2.2 Methods
Alignment. The building of full-text indexes and RNA-seq reads alignment to the reference genome was done by the HISAT2 program with the following options. [26] (Table 6.1)
hisat2 -p 8 -q --no-unal -x ../input/Pv11_5.0.final -U ../ fastq/Sample_PvR3_2/PvR3_2_ATGTCA_L005_R1_001.fastq.gz,… 2> Pvr3_2.summary | samtools view -b - >PvR3.2.bam
Differential splicing analysis. Differential splicing analysis was carried out by SAJR.[38] It splits the genome into segments, regions between 2 splicing sites, count the reads which overlapped or not the segment and inclusion ratio (psi, ??). (Formula 1 and Formula 2 for alternative first and last exons )
Also, it identifies `Constitutive' and `Alternative' segments, existing in all transcripts or only in part of them, respectively. (Figure 3.1)
, (1)
, (2)
Figure 3.1. A schematically step-by-step explanation of test and control segments' definition.
Where i - number of inclusion reads, e - number of exclusion reads, lr - length of a read, ls - length of a segment.
When all measurement was finished, segments with significantly changed inclusion ratio between stages of the dehydration-rehydration cycle were found by building and fitting GLM model in R SAJR package and Benjamini-Hochberg (`BH') correction. The threshold for the p-value was set up on 0.05. The segments were divided on up- and down-regulated by the delta PSI between stages with a threshold in 0.1. In further operations, the up- and down-regulated segments will be taken as test dataset, while resting of alternative and all constitutive segments as control datasets.
Differential expression analysis. Differential expression (DE) analysis was carried out by edgeR package in R based on genes count from SAJR.[40] Data were filtered by the expression, normalized and differentially expressed genes were figured out by GLM model and `Benjamini-Hochberg' correction. The threshold for the p-value was set up on 0.05. (Table 6.2)
Functional annotation. The most probable cDNA and corresponding proteins were extracted from the genome by `Transdecoder' and uploaded to `Interproscan' for further functional annotation of proteins. [17]The program scan sequences and find matches in the following databases: TIGRFAM, SFLD, ProDom, Hamap, SMART, CDD, ProSiteProfiles, ProSitePatterns, SUPERFAMILY, PRINTS, PANTHER, Gene3D, PIRSF, Pfam, Coils, MobiDBLite. [42]
GO enrichment analysis. So far as a functional annotation with GO id has been obtained, GO enrichment analysis was done. Genes were filtered by several parameters.
Figure 3.2. All used combinations of test dataset and background for GO enrichment analysis.
They must have GO id, count per million more than 1 on all stages of the dehydration-rehydration cycle, and contain at least one internal exon. The genes were separated on geneset by the GO id and used on the background. On the figure 3.2 below showing all variants of comparisons. Significantly enriched gene sets were identified by Fisher's exact test and `BH' correction with a threshold of 0.05.
Strength of the splicing sites. Position weight matrix (PWM) was built for splice sites and polypyrimidine tracts based on the constitutive segments by R package `Biostrings'. For both test and control datasets scores were calculated and compared by Student's t-test with the threshold for p-value in 0.05. (Figure 3.3)
Figure 3.3. Illustration of introns' selected zones for exploring the strength of the splicing sites.
One more mark of polypyrimidine tract strength is polypyrimidine enrichment of the regions. Then bigger is the purine content in the polypyrimidine tract than more reducing the affinity with U2AF. [22] CT content was found by the simple formula.
,(3)
Where C - number of cytosines, T - number of thymines, sl - sequence length.
Motif enrichment analysis. As far as motif enrichment analysis of complete introns is a long process, in the research it was done only on certain intron regions. Based on the intron length histogram, the minimum length was set on 100 nucleotides. Then without splicing sites and polypyrimidine tract, it will shorten up to 75 nucleotides. Thus test datasets contained cassette exons flanked introns not shorter than 100 nt. In the controls were selected the segments from the same genes surrounded not shorter introns.
These sets were pairwise compared to the existing of the Drosophila motifs from the CISBP-RNA database. [46] The motif enrichment analysis carried out with the `AME' tool from web-server MEME.[41] It was run with the following settings:
ame --verbose 1 --oc . --scoring totalhits --method fisher --hit-lo-fraction 0.25 --evalue-report-threshold 10.0 --control exn_upstream.fasta d_se_upstream.fasta db/CISBP-RNA/Drosophila_melanogaster.dna_encoded.meme
It uses Fisher's exact test and Bonferroni correction with threshold 0.05 for finding the significantly overrepresented motifs.
Orthologs' search. All known RNA binding proteins from the CISBP-RNA database for found enriched motifs around test segments were downloaded and concatenated with Polypedilum vanderplanki proteome from Transdecoder. This collection of amino acid sequences was uploaded as a BLAST database and ran in protein BLAST in all-against-all mode. For each motif were selected the best hit one or several proteins by E-value.[3]
3. Results and Discussion
3.1 Differential splicing analysis
The RNA-seq data consisted of five stages of dehydration/rehydration cycle (fully hydrated, 24 hours of dehydration, 48 hours of dehydration, 3 hours of rehydration and 24 hours of rehydration, two biological replicates for each stage) were mapped to the reference genome. The reads were counted, and differential splicing analysis was performed using SAJR pipeline [38]. Multidimensional scaling (MDS) plot confirms data consistency. As the PvD48 samples are most remote from PvD0 and PvR24 are the closest to it. (Figure 4.1)
Figure 4.1.Inclusion ratio MDS plot
The 1322 segments were identified as significantly changing their inclusion between fully hydrated stage and at least on stage of dehydration/rehydration cycle. (GLM, quasi likelihood ratio test, p-value < 0.05, |dPSI| > 0.1). 688 and 528 segments were up- or down-regulated at one or more stages of rehydration/dehydration cycle compared to fully hydrated form. For 106 segments change direction was different at different stages. (Table 4.1, Figure 6.1).
Table 4.1. The number of up- and down-spliced segments on different stages of the dehydration-rehydration cycle.
24 hours dehydration |
48 hours dehydration |
3 hours rehydration |
24 hours rehydration |
||
Down-regulated |
246 (19%) |
514 (39%) |
412 (31%) |
225 (17%) |
|
esp. cassette exons |
143 (11%) |
271 (20%) |
214 (16%) |
110 (8%) |
|
Up-regulated |
339 (26%) |
533 (40%) |
583 (44%) |
266 (20%) |
|
esp. cassette exons |
140 (11%) |
171 (13%) |
210 (16%) |
114 (9%) |
For down-regulated segments PSI distribution is almost uniform before desiccation and strongly skewed to zero on the vitrification stage (d48), while the up-regulated segments exhibit the opposite behavior (Figure 4.2).
However, the majority of segments demonstrated moderate amplitude of PSI change under dehydration (Figure 4.2.C).
The delta PSI mostly lay within 0.1 and 0.2, which means that the inclusion of the region reduced or increased on average 10-20% from the normal condition.
The inclusion of alternative segments' various types changes in different ways between stages of the dehydration-rehydration cycle.
Cassette exons are more often excluded from the transcript during desiccation with the peak of dropout on 48 hours, while intron retention, oppositely, increases. Alternative donor and acceptor segments also begin to be included in transcripts during dehydration and even more at the beginning of rehydration. (Table 4.1, Figure 4.3)
Thus, cassette exons' PSI decrease during desiccation, while intron retention, alternative donor and acceptor segments start to include in transcripts.
Figure 4.2. (A and B) The distribution of down- or up-regulated segments' inclusion ratio in normal active state (d0) and 48 hours of dehydration (d48). (C) The distribution of delta PSI (dPSI) for down-regulated (negative_dPSI) and up-regulated (positive_dPSI) segments at 48 hours of dehydration.
Figure 4.3. The distribution of different types of segments between anhydrobiosis stages. Abbreviations: d24 - 24 hours of dehydration; d48 - 48 hours of dehydration; r3 - 3 hours of rehydration; r24 - 24 hours of rehydration; pos_dPSI - up-regulated segments; neg_dPSI - down-regulated segments.
Using hierarchical cluster analysis with correlation distance we clustered desiccation-related segments into 5 clusters (Figure 4.4). It separated the segments into groups by patterns of their inclusion ratio changes during rehydration/dehydration cycle. In three of them segments reduce their inclusion during anhydrobiosis with a minimum PSI at 48 hours of dehydration (clusters 1 and 3) or 3 hours of rehydration (cluster 5). Segments from remaining clusters demonstrate increase of their inclusion in comparison with active larva state (clusters 2 and 4).
Figure 4.4. Cluster analysis of statistically significant differentially spliced segments.
Subsequently, all analyzes were performed exclusively on cassette segments. Firstly, because intron retention (IR) is traditionally overlooked as transcriptional noise and the methods for IR accurate detection is limited and just starting to develop. [32] Secondly, there are more cassette exons than alternative acceptors or donors in the dataset. In addition, cassette exons are predominant type AS and bringing the greatest functional changes for mRNA.[11]
3.2 Splicing sites' strength
One of the widespread observations about splicing is that alternative splicing sites are weaker than constant [28]. It causes the necessary outside intervention on alternative splice sites' selection. The strength of the splicing sites in the control and test sets was measured based on PWM and compared with each other. Both up- and down-regulated cassette exons have significantly weaker splice sites than constitutive exons from the control set (T-test, p-value < 0.05). (Figure 4.5A-B)
Figure 4.5. Pairwise comparisons of controls and test segments' (A) acceptor splice site (B) donor splice site (C) polypyrimidine tract. (D) Logo plots for acceptor, donor splice site and polypyrimidine tract. (E) CT content in polypyrimidine tract. Abbreviations: exn - constitutive segments; alt - alternative segments, but not differentially spliced; pos_dPSI - up-regulated segments; neg_dPSI - down-regulated segments. The statistically significant comparisons shown by red arrows.
However, all analysed sites are from major spliceosome GT-AG introns (Figure 4.5D). In addition, the polypyrimidine tract upstream of alternative segments is less pyrimidine enriched. (Figure 4.5C,E) The purine content in the PPT reduces affinity with U2AF and, consequently, contributes to skipping a segment.[22]
Summarizing, in P. vanderplanki all common observations for other species splicing are kept, and should exist the outside factors underlie the observed changes in alternative splicing during anhydrobiosis.
3.3 Intron length distribution
For further motifs analysis, the knowledge of intron length distribution is necessary, because it gives an understanding of the minimum threshold for flanking introns length. Distribution of intron length exhibits clear peak around 60 nt, majority (66%) of P. vanderplanki introns are short with length from 50 to 100 nt (Figure 4.6). Similar distributions were found in several other model organisms with relatively short genomes, such as Drosophila melanogaster and Caenorhabditis elegans.(Figure 4.6)[33]
Figure 4.6. Distribution of introns' length (left) in P. vanderplanki (right) in S. cerevisiae (S.ce.), C. elegans (C.el.), D. melanogaster (D.me.), A. thaliana (A.th.) and Homo sapiens (H.sa.).[33]
All cassette exons have statistically significantly longer flanking introns than constitutive segments (Wilcoxon test, p-value < 0.05).
This suggests the abundance of the exon definition mechanism in cassette exons. Consequently, the regulation elements are most probably located in introns (Figure 4.7, Table 6.3).
Figure 4.7. The distribution of introns' length splitted by datasets, where exn - constitutive segments; alt - alternative segments, but not differentially spliced; positive_dPSI - up-regulated segments; negative_dPSI - down-regulated segments.
Down-regulated segments have even longer flanking introns than up-regulated or alternative but not desiccation-related cassette exons (Wilcoxon test, p-value < 0.05).
From figure 4.7 it became obvious that included segments are closer to other alternative ones, while excluded cassette exons are much more frequently surrounded by long introns.
The following analysis was focused on cassette exons surrounded by introns longer than 100 nt.
3.4 Motif analysis
Motif enrichment analysis. Up- and down-regulated segments flanked by introns longer than 100 nt on both sides were used as test sets in motif enrichment analysis.
We formed two control sets of segments - constitutive and alternative but not differentially spliced exons. They were selected from the same genes as tests and with long introns (> 100 bp) as well.
Motif enrichment analysis resulted in the 10 motifs enriched in the test dataset compared to one of controls (Table 6.4).
Figure 4.8. Log Fold Change during anhydrobiosis of differentially expressed genes coding the RBPs binding the overrepresented motifs.
Nine of them overrepresented in down-regulated sequences and one in up-regulated. There are 71 D. melanogaster RNA-binding proteins associated with at least one of these 10 motifs. Using BLAST we found 11 P. vanderplanki closest homologs for 58 of them.
Nine of them were differentially expressed during rehydration/rehydration cycle, in particular MSTRG.614, MSTRG.4336, MSTRG.12277 and MSTRG.15360 changed their expression more than twice during anhydrobiosis. (Figure 4.8)
Domain architecture and self-regulated segments. All proteins encoded by found homologs contain RNA recognition motifs (RRM). However, the one coded by MSTRG.614 also has the ZZ domain of cytoplasmic polyadenylation element-binding protein 1. (Figure 4.9)
Figure 4.9. Motifs logos and domain architecture of corresponding P. vanderplanki RBPs. Abbreviations: RRM - RNA recognition motif; 2m13 - the zz domain of cytoplasmic polyadenylation element binding protein 1.
Moreover, the genes MSTRG.4336 and MSTRG.10095 have alternatively spliced regions surrounded by their own recognition motifs. Thus these genes could be involved in self-regulation (Figure 4.10).
The self-regulated segment in MSTRG.4336 is a 15 nucleotide sequence located in the middle of the RRM region.
It doesn't affect a lot on amino acid sequence, however, its inclusion ratio reduces on 30 % between active larva condition and 48 hours of dehydration. At the same time, the gene expression decreased (Figure 4.10).
So this region could participate in mechanisms of preventing gene silencing or repressing the splicing factor activity, as far as it locates in the middle of RRM and the hosting gene expression decreasing.
Figure 4.10. Domain architecture, inclusion ratio and gene expression changes in genes with self-spliced segments - (A) MSTRG.4336 and (B) MSTRG10095.
The segment in MSTRG.10095 behaves in another way. It is a 140 bp sequence at the beginning of the protein and causes the stop codon if excluded. Its inclusion ratio has not changed dramatically during desiccation, however, it has increased rapidly during rehydration.
The same pattern is traced in expression, it decreased in dehydration and increased in rehydration. (Figure 4.10) Probably the splicing out of the segment led to the generation of premature termination codons (PTCs) and transcript degradation by nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD). (Figure 4.11)
Figure 4.11. Schematic illustration of possible ways of splicing regulation by MSTRG.10095 encoded RNA-binding protein (M10095).
Involvement in molecular functions and biological processes. One of AME outputs is the list of true positive (TP) sequences, the segments from the test dataset with the overrepresentation of the motif in flanking introns. We calculated motif similarity based on the overlap of introns with motif matches and used this measure to split the motifs into three groups by their positive segments' intersections (Figure 4.12).
The Tra2 motif is remote from others because it is the sole motif overrepresented in the up-regulated cassette exons during dehydration. The Elav, Fne and Rbp9 also form a separate group that corresponds to motifs' nucleotide composition similarity. (Figure 4.12)
Figure 4.12. (left) Distance between groups of segments flanked by introns enriched by the corresponding motif. (right) Intersection the clusters of genes containing these segments.
The rest 5 motifs generate the third cluster, however, the Orb2 RRM stands out. The similar pattern keeps in the intersection of genes hosting the positive sequences (Figure 4.12).
Figure 4.13. (left) Molecular functions and biological processes which involve the genes with positive segments. (right) The results of GO enrichment analysis.
Figure 4.13 demonstrates molecular functions or biological processes enriched in genes containing exons that have a match of one of these 9 motifs in adjacent introns. Thus the proteins encoded by nine genes of P. vanderplanki (MSTRG.1051, MSTRG.614, MSTRG.4336, MSTRG.6810, MSTRG.7874, MSTRG.10095, MSTRG.12277, MSTRG.9458, MSTRG.15360) regulate the segments exclusion from genes that participate in such processes as mRNA processing, protein binding, signal transduction, phosphorylation, cytoskeletal protein binding and actin filament binding.
All these processes participate not only in alternative splicing auto- and cross-regulation but also in desiccation resistance in P. vanderplanki. [2, 25, 39, 44]
Conclusion
Thus, in the current research, the alternative splicing regulation pathways in Polypedilum vanderplanki were explored . Based on the results following conclusions could be done:
1) 1322 AS events exhibit statistically significant changes under dehydration-rehydration cycle. Majority of observed changes (62%) return back to pre-dehydration state after 24 h of rehydration.
2) The bigger part of differentially cassette exons demonstrates inclusion decrease during desiccation, while PSI of the majority of alternative donors, alternative acceptor, and intron retention increases.
3) Alternative segments in Polypedilum vanderplanki are surrounded by weak splicing sites and the polypyrimidine tract is less enriched in pyrimidine.
4) Two classes of Polypedilum vanderplanki introns were discovered: short (50-100 nt, 66 %) and long (>100 nt). Desiccation-related cassette exons much more frequently than expected by chance surrounded by long introns (Wilcoxon test, p-value < 0.05).
5) Based in motif enrichment analysis 11 RNA-binding proteins were implicated in AS regulation during desiccation. Nine of them were marked as differentially expressed, in particular MSTRG.614, MSTRG.4336, MSTRG.12277 and MSTRG.15360 changed their expression more than twice during anhydrobiosis.
6) The genes MSTRG.4336 and MSTRG.10095 are suggested to have spliced out segments under their own proteins' regulation. These segments' exclusion leads to reducing splicing factor activity and premature stop codon generation with following transcript degradation, respectively.
7) The genes regulated by found nine putative splicing factors involved in alternative splicing self-regulation and desiccation resistance processes in Polypedilum vanderplanki.
Directions for future research:
1) Compare test and control datasets by protein features (signatures, domains) and figure out if there some features prefer to locate around alternative segments rather than constitutive ones. Also, review the literature if these features' preferences have already shown for other organisms or they are specific for P. vanderplanki.
2) Construct the biological validation experiment for the regulation of cassette exons splicing out by found nine putative desiccation-related splicing factors. Presumably, it will be the knockdown experiment with siRNA modeling for each mRNA. The role of RBPs will be estimated by comparison of survival rate, expression and splicing between cells with knockdown and wild type.
References
1. Berk A.J., Sharp P.A. Sizing and mapping of early adenovirus mRNAs by gel electrophoresis of S1 endonuclease-digested hybrids // Cell. 1977. № 3 (12). C. 721-732.
2. Blaustein M. [и др.]. Concerted regulation of nuclear and cytoplasmic activities of SR proteins by AKT // Nature structural & molecular biology. 2005. № 12 (12). C. 1037-1044.
3. Boratyn G.M. [и др.]. Magic-BLAST, an accurate RNA-seq aligner for long and short reads // BMC bioinformatics. 2019. № 1 (20). C. 405.
4. Chen F. [и др.]. OrthoMCL-DB: querying a comprehensive multi-species collection of ortholog groups // Nucleic acids research. 2006. № Database issue (34). C. D363-8.
5. Chen M., Manley J.L. Mechanisms of alternative splicing regulation: insights from molecular and genomics approaches // Nature reviews. Molecular cell biology. 2009. № 11 (10). C. 741-754.
6. Chow L.T. [и др.]. A map of cytoplasmic RNA transcripts from lytic adenovirus type 2, determined by electron microscopy of RNA:DNA hybrids // Cell. 1977. № 4 (11). C. 819-836.
7. Cornette R. [и др.]. Identification of Anhydrobiosis-related Genes from an Expressed Sequence Tag Database in the Cryptobiotic MidgePolypedilum vanderplanki(Diptera; Chironomidae) // Journal of Biological Chemistry. 2010. Т. 285. № 46. 35889-35899 с.
8. Crowe J.H. Trehalose As a “Chemical Chaperone” // Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology. 143-158 с.
9. Crowe J.H., Carpenter J.F., Crowe L.M. The role of vitrification in anhydrobiosis // Annual review of physiology. 1998. (60). C. 73-103.
10. Crowe J.H., Madin K.A. Anhydrobiosis in Tardigrades and Nematodes // Transactions of the American Microscopical Society. 1974. Т. 93. № 4. 513 с.
11. Cui Y., Cai M., Stanley H.E. Comparative Analysis and Classification of Cassette Exons and Constitutive Exons // BioMed research international. 2017. (2017). C. 7323508.
12. Dvinge H. Regulation of alternative mRNA splicing: old players and new perspectives // FEBS letters. 2018. № 17 (592). C. 2987-3006.
13. Erkut C. [и др.]. How worms survive desiccation // Worm. 2012. Т. 1. № 1. 61-65 с.
14. Fica S.M., Nagai K. Cryo-electron microscopy snapshots of the spliceosome: structural insights into a dynamic ribonucleoprotein machine // Nature structural & molecular biology. 2017. № 10 (24). C. 791-799.
15. Gusev O. [и др.]. Expression of heat shock protein-coding genes associated with anhydrobiosis in an African chironomid Polypedilum vanderplanki // Cell Stress and Chaperones. 2011. Т. 16. № 1. 81-90 с.
16. Gusev O. [и др.]. Comparative genome sequencing reveals genomic signature of extreme desiccation tolerance in the anhydrobiotic midge // Nature Communications. 2014. Т. 5. № 1.
17. Haas B.J. [и др.]. De novo transcript sequence reconstruction from RNA-seq using the Trinity platform for reference generation and analysis // Nature protocols. 2013. № 8 (8). C. 1494-1512.
18. Hatanaka R. [и др.]. Diversity of the expression profiles of late embryogenesis abundant (LEA) protein encoding genes in the anhydrobiotic midge Polypedilum vanderplanki // Planta. 2015. № 2 (242). C. 451-459.
19. Hinton H.E. Cryptobiosis in the larva of Polypedilum vanderplanki Hint. (Chironomidae) // Journal of Insect Physiology. 1960. Т. 5. № 3-4. 286-300 с.
20. Horowitz D.S., Abelson J. Stages in the second reaction of pre-mRNA splicing: the final step is ATP independent // Genes & Development. 1993. Т. 7. № 2. 320-329 с.
21. Iordachescu M., Imai R. Trehalose and Abiotic Stress in Biological Systems // Abiotic Stress in Plants - Mechanisms and Adaptations. 2011.
22. Jeanteur P. Regulation of Alternative Splicing / P. Jeanteur, Springer Science & Business Media, 2013. 245 c.
23. Khanna A., Stamm S. Regulation of alternative splicing by short non-coding nuclear RNAs // RNA biology. 2010. № 4 (7). C. 480-485.
24. Kikawada T. [и др.]. Dehydration-induced expression of LEA proteins in an anhydrobiotic chironomid // Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications. 2006. Т. 348. № 1. 56-61 с.
25. Kikawada T. [и др.]. Dehydration-inducible changes in expression of two aquaporins in the sleeping chironomid, Polypedilum vanderplanki // Biochimica et biophysica acta. 2008. № 2 (1778). C. 514-520.
...Подобные документы
Nature of infrared analysis and nature of mass spectrometry. Summary of the uses in forensic analysis. Critical comparison of infrared analysis and spectrometry. Gathering of the information about positional isomers with the help of infrared analysis.
эссе [21,8 K], добавлен 08.12.2011The complement system - part of the immune system as a set of complex proteins. History of the concept. Its biological functions, regulation, role in diseases. Stages of activation: the alternative and lectin pathway. Mannose-binding Lectin deficiency.
презентация [932,7 K], добавлен 17.03.2017Ensuring access to health care (on the example, Novo Nordisk). Comparison of of different companies: sales growth and margin, ROE, returns stock price. Relationship between ATM index and stock returns. Strategic pillars of the pharmaceutical companies.
презентация [935,7 K], добавлен 18.10.2015Classification of the resistance. External and internal barnry protecting the human body from pathological factors of the environment. The chemical composition of the blood, its role and significance. Influence the age on individual reactivity progeria.
презентация [4,5 M], добавлен 17.10.2016The physiological, hygienic and epidemiological value of water. Diseases associated with water factor. Measures to prevent transmission of infectious diseases through the water. Influence of biological factors on survival of microorganisms in water.
презентация [762,9 K], добавлен 17.05.2016Tachycardia is a heart rate that exceeds the normal range. Symptoms and treatment methods of tachycardia. An electrocardiogram (ECG) is used to classify the type of tachycardia. It's important to get a prompt, accurate diagnosis and appropriate care.
презентация [596,2 K], добавлен 20.11.2014Anatomical and physiological concepts about the structure and functions of the peripheral nervous system. Role of the autonomic nervous system in the regulation of the internal organs of the organism. The structure of the cranial and spinal nerves PNS.
презентация [326,9 K], добавлен 21.05.2014A brief sketch of the life and professional development of Botkin as the Russian scientist, a gifted doctor. Botkin's value in world medicine, assessment of its scientific achievements. Analysis and themes of famous doctor, the direction of its research.
презентация [1,7 M], добавлен 10.12.2014Study of method of determining the amount of osteocyte lacunar and estimation of specific numerical closeness of lacunes by a three-dimensional impartial expecting method at the analysis of anisotropy of types of the vascular ductings of human bone.
реферат [8,6 K], добавлен 01.12.2010Analysis of factors affecting the health and human disease. Determination of the risk factors for health (Genetic Factors, State of the Environment, Medical care, living conditions). A healthy lifestyle is seen as the basis for disease prevention.
презентация [1,8 M], добавлен 24.05.2012The Keynesian concept in economic of endogenous cycles seems to require non-linear structures. One of the theories of business cycles in the Keynesian vein is that expounded in a pioneering article by N. Kaldor. Non-linear dynamics of the Kaldor's cycle.
контрольная работа [233,8 K], добавлен 18.07.2009The pillars of any degree of comparison. Morphological composition of the adjectives. An introduction on degrees of comparison. Development and stylistic potential of degrees of comparison. General notes on comparative analysis. Contrastive linguistics.
курсовая работа [182,5 K], добавлен 23.12.2014Purpose of the Marketing Plan. Organization Mission Statement. The main strategies employed by BMW. Sales volume of automobiles. New records set for revenues and earnings. Current models of BMW. Product life cycle. Engagement in Celebrity Endorsement.
курсовая работа [879,4 K], добавлен 03.05.2015Path of blood through the heart. The cardiac cycle. Cardiac Output. The Heartbeat. Intrinsic Control of Heartbeat. Conduction system of the heart. Extrinsic Control of Heartbeat. The Electrocardiogram. The cross-sectional area of arteries and arterioles.
презентация [355,7 K], добавлен 27.10.2013The process of scientific investigation. Contrastive Analysis. Statistical Methods of Analysis. Immediate Constituents Analysis. Distributional Analysis and Co-occurrence. Transformational Analysis. Method of Semantic Differential. Contextual Analysis.
реферат [26,5 K], добавлен 31.07.2008Международный стандарт ISO/IEC 12207:1995 ”Information Technology – Software Life Cycle Processes” (ГОСТ Р ИСО/МЭК 12207-99) определяющий структуру ЖЦ, содержащую процессы, которые должны быть выполнены во время создания программного обеспечения.
презентация [519,6 K], добавлен 19.09.2016A bank: nature of activity, main business-processes and organizational structure, the market place and history. Definitions of the project and project management, the project life cycle. Management of development projects in a bank, the expected results.
реферат [20,6 K], добавлен 14.02.2016Adjectives and comparatives in modern English. Definition, grammatical overview of the term adjectives. Expression and forms of comparative in the language. Morphological, lexical ways of expressing. Features and basic principles of their expression.
курсовая работа [37,0 K], добавлен 30.01.2016Estimation de l'unite de la resistance des materiaux largement utilises dans les structures statiques et des disciplines connexes a la conception de pieces de machines, les batiments, ponts et routes. Analyse de l'etat de contraintes dans de la tige.
контрольная работа [397,1 K], добавлен 16.12.2012The essence of Natural Monopoly. The necessity of regulation over Natural Monopoly. Methods of state regulation over the Natural Monopolies. Analysis and Uzbek practice of regulation over Monopolies. Natural Monopolies in modern Economy of Uzbekistan.
курсовая работа [307,7 K], добавлен 13.03.2014