Comparing instructional design model

Размещено на http://www.allbest.ru/

The aim of this report compares instructional design models. Instructional design model is approaching creating rules to address into learning. In instructional design models address to learning theory and then instructional design method.

Instructional design model represents an issue revealing design task to negotiate with grasp. Models demonstrate the issue and to divide into units, particular model depends on context which is utilized. Designer desire a model being mediates and share workload and change concentration from itself to design activity.

Hannafin & Peck Model/ Knirk & Gustafson Model

The Knirk and Gustafson Design Model

The Knirk and Gustafson Design Model, separates by three stages:

Determination. This stage is about defining the issue and making goals.

Design. Second stage comprises objectives and strategies evolved. Different media are included in this stage and that used to carry between radio and computer. Within of time what is accessible and necessary.

Development. The final step is improving materials. If any materials exist, this will be utilized but if not this must be created. After founding and using materials and it supposes to evaluate. In this stage we analyze product and process and after that suppose to do its revision.

The model was designed for simulation and that may easy to utilize by adept and beginner.

Hannafin & Peck Model

This model presents by three phases:

Assessment of performance. In this phase should do an analysis of definite programs. Reasonable goals are designed in this model;

Design phase. It's a central phase of the model serves to reaching goals;

Instruction is development and implementation. In this program is made decision to proceed phase or revise it.

This phase is used for embedding in process of revision and evaluation. This model is complexity for beginner and that has constrained to quality. This model conforms for simulation.

The distinction of this model and others is an evaluation of each phase. This model transforms to the elementary model of using. Any designer has iore to use the Hannafin Peck Model.

DICK and CAREY

Approach of system is used to create instruction. Iterative process in the model by defining aims and completes with assessment. Embracing areas are K-12 to business to government and users (novice to expert).

instructional learning assimilation simulation

Ausubel Assimilation Theory / Reigeluth Elaboration Theory

Elaboration Theory (Charlie Reigeluth)

In elaboration theory was organized like strict hierarchy of intricacy for learning. Instructors must remind to learner about versions. The learner should improve a meaningful context has successive ideas and knack which may be adopted; this is main conception.

This theory offers seven features:

Elaborative sequence is transitioning from simple to complex as that the first lesson embodies the ideas and knock. Epitomizing is based on detached type of content; some of the types develop synchronously and engage learning of some representative or fundamental ideas and skills.

Learning prerequisite sequences, In this level content should be arranged and that process simultaneously implements with the first level. On the relationship between levels is based on content.

Summary, this is systematically survey of articles (topics).

Synthesis. This step integrates to interrelating the ideas have taught thus far. The goal is to facilitate deeper understanding, meaningfulness, and retention in regards to the content area.

Analogies, trainer may use this component of achieving learner's experience. Analogies aid the trainer in reaching the learner's field of experience. Analogies of instruction aid the learner to build knowledge or skills.

Cognitive strategies, it has following strategies: Imbedded -- elements such as diagrams, pictures compel the learner to interact with content.

Detached -- learner is invoked to utilize prior knowledge.

Learner has controlled. Learner cans to define content, rate, components

The elaborated method should be the formation of steady cognitive structures, but that transfer and retention, strengthen the motivation of learners via meaningful context; information should be supplying content and provide monitoring of understanding of learners.

Application

This theory exists to create instructions for cognitive domain. In higher education and training apply settings of the theoretical structure.

Ausubel's Assimilation Theory

This theory focus on `meaningful learning' which information is connected to an aspect of the personal's knowledge framework. In this component of theory has short and long term memory in cognitive information. It has affective, cognitive and psychomotor.

Two aspects were secreted rote and meaningful learning. Rote learning is not learning of high level.

Difference between meaningful and rote learning.

In cognitive structure includes meaningful learning (anchored and integrated). In the information presented learner identifies meaning.

Presented new ideas are more significant for learning those related to others ideas, but learner might be connected with other if he not possesses ideas.

Introduced knowledge of rote learning is unrelated to the concept and will be forgotten.

In meaningful learning make demands of learners and teachers:

Subsumptive: The learner's appropriate preceding knowledge [2].

Superordinate:The teacher building of meaningful learning.

Combinatorial: The learner selects to utilize meaningful learning.

The ADDIE model is especially created for instructional designers and training developers as that is type of process. The ADDIE is core of instructional design, it's fundamental of the instructional design model. It includes 5 cyclical phases: analysis , design, development, implementation and evaluation. All these processes depict a flexible and dynamic guideline for construction of training and tools. This model is a contribution to championing a system of instruction as contrary to sight of instruction. Dick & Carey model has more stages than ADDIE. The model of Dick & Carey has outlined sub-tasks within the ADDIE but has relationship with principle stages of ISD. This detailing may sometimes extend the ISD in many components such as resources, learning objectives, time frame and finances. The Dick and Carrey Model has required by small group of leaner's but that demands non-linear planning. In small group is better to evaluate first stages of the ISD should be executed.

Jerold Kemp identifies 9 various aspects of an instructional design and applies components such as implementation and evaluation model. Kemp applies an oval form of this model transfer that the development and design process is cycled that demand design, development, planning and evaluation. The model is better for evolving instructional program that stirring pedagogy, technology and content. The model is suitable for designer to work because of systemic and nonlinear.

Jerrold Kemp Design Model comprises factors: learning objectives, teaching activities, resources (computers, books, etc.), subject analysis, learner characteristics, support services and evaluation. Revision and iterative are into process.

Jerrold Kemp and ICARE models have differences :

Kemp

ICARE

Human resources and Development based

Pedagogy based

More is compromised in the management components

More is included with personal learner or learning process

Focused on front end analysis

Similarities

To advance personal performance

Learning theories and information technology underlie on these models

Instructional practice based on research

Bloom's Taxonomy

The idea of this model sorts level of behavior in learning. From students demand to ponder at the lowest level because of Bloom discover test question where more students have been encountered. Bloom defined 6 levels from simple to complex recall into cognitive domain; this is the abstraction mental level for sorting and assessment.

ASSURE Model

This is the kind of a process to be utilized by the instructor in the classroom. Suitable learning for students is process of instructors to elaborate and design. It's a useful process in writing lesson and evolving teaching and learning.

ABCD Format

Writing objectives are beginning point for writing objectives of ABCD.

Tripp and Bichelmeyer

Four process focus on to design instruction for lesson as resisted whole curricula.

Prototyping is an approach to instructional design. Some processes have been occurring in a linear fashion into overlapping boxes. Knowledge consist analysis and content and that using and building a prototype system.

Originated in manufacturing

ID hijacked from software development

Focused on development primarily

Types of prototypes

Look-and-feel: colors, effects, gross screen layouts

Media: use of sound effects, narration, 3D illustrations, video, etc.

Navigation: move through sections, access support (glossary, calculator, etc.)

Interactivity: content, activities, feedback [17].

This model has differed from traditional ISD prescribe restraining of design decisions as that select practical design principle of obligation based on confining and synthesizing of solution issues at the phase.

Gerlach & Ely Model.

The model comprises instruction which needs to contribute value in learning and teaching approach

Model is a that is well suited to K-12 and higher education. It is meant for novice instructional designers who have knowledge and expertise in a specific context. The model includes strategies for selecting and including media within instruction. It also handles the allocation of resources.

K-12 and higher education has been applied into The Gerlach-Ely Design as so prescriptive model. For beginner has experience and knowledge in context.

Varied ID models have been analyzed components and instruction which resembled. In one model has various components dissimilar name or phases have been gathered into one phase to design efficient instruction.

Traditional instructional is design model that emphasis meaning as `classroom'. Leaner may improve the skills from leaning activities as well as instructor reacts on the results of individual to evolve efficient activities. The rigid method has been prescribed in the traditional design model mindless of contextual as well as policies and results described by instructor reckon leaner studied similar things and time at classroom. Instructors give one's attention to the approaches of IDM to be studied and awareness prior transactions. These traditional ID models (Rapid Prototyping, ADDIE, Hannafin Peck,Gerlach & Ely, Knrik & Gustafson , Kemp, Dick & Carey) have been condemned due to process-oriented instead people-oriented because of process of models linear and bureaucratic.

To compare ISD and ID models, the first includes 5 levels: Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation and Evaluations but second comprises two stages from upper levels: analysis and design. Theories and principles of ISD integrate in the procedures manual for progression. The ISD defines an education environment for utilizing as well as assess the instruction to identify what is needed. ID model is based on analysis of knowledge or skills and transform the analysis into strategy.

Instructional Design Models includes:

Fixed

Similar method variable was ordered regardless of activity of learner (prescriptive).

Adaptive

Learner activities or responses play main role and method variable depends on learner (descriptive)

Prescriptive includes:

Methods have been prescribed kits of conditions and results.

Aim oriented.

The best methods define variables of interest.

Kits of conditions and results have been prescribed in the entire models.

Descriptive

Kits of conditions have prescribed as given, variables of interest and results.

Aim free.

Variable of interest is presented as results.

Entire models are utilized results and that under varying.

Categories of ID models:

Conceptual

Time-focused: Learners of firmness may be provided in occasions.

Task-focused: processes are generalized and prescriptive to assist learning.

Learner-focused: instructions are founded on diversity in the learner and perspective.

Procedural

Phases are not connected with variables that use as conversion from theory to practice and presented linear.

Models based on systems theory.

Models founded on instructional theory and learning which utilized as planning instrument but not guidelines for activities.

Conclusion

Different approaches, methods and phases, area for using (web learning, K-12, higher education etc.) apply by these models. And difference these models exist amount of phases and that influence on learning process. In the process should pass all phases present to learners.

Размещено на Allbest.ru