Women’s tendency in work involvement: a study of female labor force in Indonesia

Patriarchal culture of the people and gender inequality in work. The potential and abilities of Indonesian women in raising the national economy. A study of the impact of household responsibilities, wages and education on women's labor participation.

Рубрика Социология и обществознание
Вид статья
Язык английский
Дата добавления 04.09.2024
Размер файла 351,0 K

Отправить свою хорошую работу в базу знаний просто. Используйте форму, расположенную ниже

Студенты, аспиранты, молодые ученые, использующие базу знаний в своей учебе и работе, будут вам очень благодарны.

Размещено на http://www.Allbest.Ru/

Universitas Brawijaya

Women's tendency in work involvement: a study of female labor force in Indonesia

S.E. Yuniashri

R.P. Handrito

Malang, Indonesia

Ghent, Belgium

Abstract

Culture is perceived as the most prominent factor which causes inequality in work involvement, especially in the context of gender. In many cultures, “glass ceiling” of gender bias often makes women less productive than their male counterparts because of their domestic duties. As a matter of fact, Indonesian women have proven their potentials and abilities in boosting the national economy. This study focuses on the effect of domestic duties, wages, and education on women's participation in the workforce. Using logistic regression and SUSENAS 2018 dataset, this research finds that women with higher education and greater number of children do not get involved in the workforce. This situation is inextricably associated with the predominant patriarchal culture in their domestic lives, in which the husbands assume absolute control, and women's roles are usually limited to domestic sphere. As is the case of the other workers, women are more engaged in their work when they get higher wages. Women who live in urban areas tend to have opportunities to be economically productive.

Keywords: female lab our, labor force, Indonesian women labor participation

Анотація

Схильність жінок до участі в роботі: дослідження жіночої робочої сили в Індонезії

Культура сприймається як найважливіший фактор, який спричиняє нерівність у трудовій діяльності, особливо в контексті статі. У багатьох культурах «скляна стеля» гендерних упереджень часто робить жінок менш продуктивними, ніж їхні колеги-чоловіки, через виконання домашніх обов'язків. Власне кажучи, індонезійські жінки довели свій потенціал і здібності у піднесенні національної економіки. Це дослідження зосереджено на впливі домашніх обов'язків, заробітної плати та освіти на участь жінок у робочій силі. Використовуючи логістичну регресію та набір даних SUSENAS 2018, це дослідження виявило, що жінки з вищою освітою та більшою кількістю дітей не беруть участь у робочій силі. Ця ситуація нерозривно пов'язана з панівною патріархальною культурою в їх домашньому житті, в якій чоловіки беруть на себе абсолютний контроль, а ролі жінок зазвичай обмежуються домашньою сферою. Як і у випадку з іншими працівниками, жінки більш залучені до своєї роботи, коли отримують вищу зарплату. Жінки, які живуть у містах, як правило, мають можливості бути економічно продуктивними.

Ключові слова: наша жіноча лабораторія, робоча сила, трудова участь індонезійських жінок

Introduction

Inequality has been a global problem plaguing many nations (Ville et al., 2023). Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) prioritises eradication of inequality considering that it constitutes the prime culprit of poverty in addition to numerous environmental and societal problems (Baublyte et al., 2019). Furthermore, equality has always been an issue that affects wages, career, and work (Bai et al., 2023; Johansson et al., 2019; Ismail et al., 2017). Gender inequality, in particular, can occur in economic activities and creates discrepancies that affect both women and men (Akhtar et al., 2023). Gender inequality prevents women from participating in economic engagements, and this in turn will hamper the economic growth and undermine national resilience (Bastian et al., 2019). Previous research findings have shown that reducing problems related to gender inequality can bring positive impacts on economic growth (Braunstein et al., 2020; Minasyan et al., 2019; Cuberes & Teignier, 2014).

Within their economic context, work involvement and career achievement are deemed important since they give people the opportunity to enhance their life quality. However, inequality is still haunting working environment, especially when it comes to gender. Due to “glass ceiling” gender bias, women are frequently placed in a position lower than men. Their limited opportunities to pursue a better life has been a classic issue in the recent decades. Unfortunately, this condition is aggravated when they are married and have children. This issue arises especially in developing countries, where awareness of gender equality is low and where the authorities fail to prioritize this issue in their policies. To be specific, married female labor force is an important issue in economic development because the prevailing social and cultural norms put a lot of limitations on married women in terms of employment (Lari et al., 2022). Female labor force participation is usually restricted by husbands' decisions (Korotayev et al., 2015). Within the household, men reserve the prerogative to decide whether or not women can work (Majbouri, 2020).

Clear understanding of this phenomenon is essential so that policies regarding this issue can be formulated and communicated to the general stakeholders. Moreover, abolishing gender equality will provide women with social and personal benefits of achieving economic goals like better access to markets and resources, decent work and welfare, and increased participation in economic decision-making process. Furthermore, empowering women by reducing gender inequality will improve the quality of children's health, their upbringing and education, as well as their chances of becoming quality human resources (Alloatti, 2019). Different contexts and backgrounds on the national level necessitate specific research on the national scale. In particular, ameliorating the problems of gender inequality starts with improving human resources, which can take various forms or methods such increasing working women's skills and productivity, and reducing child mortality rate and preventing early pregnancy (Braunstein et al., 2020).

This study aims to explore the relationship between women's marital status and their decision to work by reviewing variables such as level of education, regional minimum wage, number of children, and area of residence in Indonesia. Indonesia was selected as the research locale because in this country female labor force makes significant contribution to the national economy. According to the Indonesian Ministry of Finance, the country's economic success is attested by 97% of women's involvement in economic activities. The large number of women in Indonesia compared to its neighboring countries can show the potential for superior economic growth through the proper use of human resources. In addition, the role of culture was included as a new determinant for understanding and addressing to the issue of inequality in developing countries and big economies.

Literature review. Inequality is defined as one form of injustice. UNDP in 2013 stated that inequality is broad in its scope; it can occur in various world populations, social strata, and afflict people living below the poverty line. Inequality is often associated with social and economic segregation. This barrier can have an impact on social classes through income gap; the situation gives privileges to richer people, and marginalize the poor (Adeosun & Owolabi, 2021). Gender inequality occurs more frequently in developing countries than in developed countries (Iqbal et al., 2022). One of the causes is the mindset of people living in developing countries. They confine themselves to traditional values, and this creates a barrier preventing them from advancing. These people will be left behind unless they keep abreast of the dynamics of an increasingly modern world. Another recurring problem in developing countries is religious tension, which creates political instability, division, and eventually, gender inequality (Ahmed & Brasted, 2021). Gender inequality in economic sector is quite detrimental because it limits women's opportunity for self-expression (Bastian et al., 2019). The perpetual inequality and gender stereotypes will create a barrier in the labor market through inefficiencies (Klemparskyi et al., 2022). When it comes to corporate territory, women's role on company's boards is minimal. Corporate boards of director are usually dominated by men. According to ILO's report, over 76% companies have a male chairman on the board. Companies with women presiding as CEO's tend to be smaller in size compared to those led by men. Of course, these companies are often less profitable because of their lower rate of growth. Studies from the OECD state that many women-led companies are engaged in wholesale and retail trade.

Discussions on gender segregation can never exclude gender inequality. Providing self-development opportunities for women will encourage them to maximize their talents and potentials, and this effort can overcome gender segregation across companies. In addition, such effort also provides opportunities for men to fill certain positions that are traditionally not open for them. As a rule of thumb, every government has it in their agenda to build a highly developed and prosperous country. To this end, productive investments conducive to economic development are high in demand. Productive investment should take the form of education and health services for the population. It is expected that investments in this sector will promote quality human resources capable of competing in the global arena. There have been many theories of human capital. The notion of rational choice has now expanded the notion of human capital. Both ideas can explain gender inequality on the economic side. The rational choice theory asserts that individuals can choose to act according to their interests that are based on economic activities, but individuals also have the freedom to refuse. Closely connected to the human capital theory is the idea that rational choices depend on what people can achieve and what they have achieved, and this in turn is conditioned by the quality of human resources. Gender inequality is a recurring problem in poor countries. For example, Ghanian women suffer from educational inequality (Senadza, 2012) which prevents them from getting involved in work force and earning wages. In Nigeria, women, especially those living in rural areas, also face wage inequality and have limited access to resources (Adeosun & Owolabi, 2021). South Asian women suffer from gender inequality in wages because of differences in education levels. Women who take primary and tertiary education are less susceptible to wage inequality, while those who have secondary education are more prone to wage inequality (Munir & Kanwal, 2020). Paradoxically, women who enjoy higher education show less tendency to engage in work when they get married (Berniell et al., 2021). Reduced wage inequality between men and women is expected to improve the national economy since women's involvement in work is a potential leverage for economic growth (Bloom et al., 2009) through increased productivity in companies (Larson, 2020). This study examines factors affecting women's work engagement using a quantitative approach.

Education

Women and men have different ideas about their involvement in education (Awaworyi Churchill et al., 2019). Women tend to have lower education because marriage will limit their activities within the boundary of domestic affairs and rearing children, which is a stark contrast to men who are encouraged to enjoy higher education (Assaad et al., 2017). Statistics Indonesia states that women's involvement in education in urban and rural areas from 2016 to 2020 has always been lower than that of men. Especially at the senior high school level and above in rural areas, annual statistics shows that the percentage of women's involvement never exceeds the 30-percent level. Conversely, men's involvement rate in education continues to increase. High school education level and above in urban areas is always dominated by men, with the percentage that exceeds 50%. Women mostly have a lower level of education than men, showing the influence of culture on education. In essence, education equality, shown by the involvement of education, contributes to economic growth (Altuzarra, 2021).

In fact, women's involvement in higher education will potentially change their mindset as they become more open-minded and can get decent jobs in various economic activities (Abraham et al., 2017; Rendall, 2013). There are similarities between gender inequality-economic growth relationship and gender inequality-education relationship (Altuzarra, 2021). Women with higher levels of education tend to be more involved in the labor market than those with lower levels of education (Gavriluta et al., 2022). Women with higher education tend to have better skills and more job opportunities matching their skills (Assaad et al., 2020; Podder, 2018). Husbands' level of education increase women's involvement in work. Thanks to higher education, men can accept women's involvement in the labor market (Dawood et al., 2019). Additionally, men who can access higher education - whether they are married or not - will be more aware of the encroaching patriarchal power and try to fight it (Ennaji, 2016).

Regional minimum wage

Regional minimum wage is basically a policy instrument to ensure decent wage for workers. Regional minimum wage is calculated based on various aspects such as inflation, price of goods, and productivity. Although debates over regional minimum wage setting and its outcomes are frequent and politically entrenched (Ford & Gillan, 2017), regional minimum wages should be the price floor to protect vulnerable workers. However, in practice, the regional minimum wage is the benchmark figure for hiring workers. Hence, workers continue to earn less than regional minimum wage. Another lingering problem in Indonesia is wage inequality. Gender wage inequality can occur in both low-income and high-income occupations (Rudakov et al., 2022; Shoham & Lee, 2018). In spite of the explanations made to account for wage differentials, one cannot deny the fact that men earn more than women do. Men tend to get prioritized in work recruitments and continue to get more opportunities. Women tend to be neglected because they need to spend a lot of time and energy on household chores. As a consequence, the only jobs left for them are part-time jobs, jobs with few demands, and little pay. During recruitment process, women are not prioritized while male worker enjoy longer work hours (Medina-Hernandez et al., 2021), and earn higher wages in the labour market (Akhtar et al., 2023; Belasen & Angiello, 2018; Larraz et al., 2019; Jara Diaz & Candia Riquelme, 2017). An increase in wage supply will increase women's interest in engaging in work (De Hoyos, 2011), although this principle applies also to men.

Number of children

Economic growth as a condition for national development requires both men and women to engage in work. The involvement of a large number of women in productive work is a telltale mark of the most significant social transformation (Moon & Hasan, 2022). Traditionally, women have responsibilities for childcare and domestic work. Along with the growing number of women who get higher education, anxiety rises among mothers who also wish to be economically productive. This is a common sight at present (Korabik & Warner, 2013; Poduval & Poduval, 2009; Dorio et al., 2008; De Cieri et al., 2005). Previous studies reveal that many married women aspire to be economically productive, but they tend to get shorter work hours (Pratomo, 2014).

However, some women show the proclivity to be family-oriented; they believe they have central position in domestic affairs. They steadfastly adhere to conservative values about their domestic roles. They tend to spend time with their children and work close to home. Gender segregation only becomes a problem when they enter the labor market where they expect to get part-time and flexible jobs. Women who do not have children tend to use their time to improve their education and engage in economic activities (Bearak et al., 2021). In addition, women who already have children tend to earn lower wages than those who do not (England et al., 2016; Florian, 2018). Families with more dependents need higher income because spending on education and children's health will automatically increase. It is this form of gender inequality that ultimately deters women from joining female workforce and increases their fertility (Kizilova & Mosakova, 2019). Ultimately, this phenomenon will create a vicious circle in women's labor market. The number of dependencies in the family should be a good driver for women's labor force participation (Marois et al., 2022).

Area of residence

Increased women's employment opportunities may not align with women's labor force participation due to inherent cultural values (Undurraga & Gunnarsson, 2021). In Indonesia, life in rural areas is still laden with cultural values, especially those that affect women. This phenomenon affects the supply of labor, where in urban areas the opportunity to work is ample and offers high wages, even for women (Hasan & Molato, 2019). In rural areas, agriculture dominates employment, and female workers tend to be vulnerable to poverty (Dawood et al., 2019). In addition, waging system in rural areas tend to be less effective (Pratomo, 2014). With the the increasing number of modern, urban women with improved mindset along with improved urban waging system, there is an increase in their work involvement compared to their rural counterparts. In addition, the availability of more diverse jobs in urban areas will increase women's involvement in work.

Research method

This study uses quantitative approach and logistic regression analysis. Logistic regression is one way to analyse the dichotomous dependent variable's characteristics (namely Y = 0 and Y = 1). The logistic regression analysis method regresses the Y variable with X or (independent variable). In this study, the independent variables are as follows:

Table 1

Variable Explanation

This study uses data acquired from the 2018 SUSENAS (National Socioeconomic Survey) and from 2018 Statistics Indonesia. SUSENAS dataset is issued triennially, while the Statistics Indonesia dataset is issued annually. The survey was designed to collect population social data with the coverage of 83%. The data were collected through direct visits and interviews conducted by Statistics Indonesia enumerators. In general, SUSENAS dataset was collected with the aim of designing better plans necessary for making the right policies based on the data at hand. All data variables are collected from SUSENAS. However, due to limited data, the data for the regional minimum wages were collected from Statistics Indonesia.

Based on the explanation provided in the introduction section and the support of the theories and past studies, the hypotheses of this research are as follows.

Hi... women with higher level of education are more involved in work

H2... women with higher wage are more involved in work.

H3... women with larger number of children are more motivated to be involved in work.

H4... women living in urban areas are more involved in work.

Results and discussion

This study examines married Javanese women of productive age (15-64 years). The total number of respondents is 94,561.

The Table 1 presents the results of SUSENAS data processing, and the resulting values are explained in the table below.

Table 2

Descriptive statistics

Y

Mean

Std. Dev.

Min

Max

Education Level

9.187

3.414

6

22

Regional Minimum Wage

2,113,894

490,021.1

1,454,154

3,648,036

Number of Children

4.581

1.551

1

11

Area of Residence

0.427

0.494

0

1

Source: self-processed data

Based on the results of the data processing in STATA, the general description of the independent variable data distribution center shows that the average level of education taken by the respondents is 9 years, or up to Junior High School. In this case, this level of education is considered to be low. In the regional minimum wage variable, the average value is IDR 2,113,894. Statistics Indonesia classifies this average as moderate. The average number of children owned by women in this study is 4, and in average, the women live in urban areas.

The results of the statistical tests with logistic regression models are as follows.

Table 3

Variables in Equations

Y

Coefficient

Std. Error

Z

P.Value

Odds Ratio

Education Level

-0.0641

0.0021

-29.32

0.000

0.9378

Regional Minimum Wage

0.3462

0.0114

30.31

0.000

1.4137

Number of Children

-0.0449

0.0090

-4.99

0.000

0.9560

Area of Residence

0.1128

0.0143

7.88

0.000

1.1194

Cons

-0.5836

0.0370

-15.75

0.000

0.5578

Source: self-processed data

Based on the results of data processing, the logistic regression formula is as follows.

LN((P(Y=1))/(1-P(Y=1))) = - 0.5836 - 0.0641 (Education Level) + 0.3462

(Regional Minimum Wage) - 0,0449 (Number of Children) - 0,1128 (Area

of Residence) (1)

In terms educational level, the estimation show a significant negative coefficient, which means that the higher education taken by the married female labour force, the lower their chance of being engaged in work. The odd ratio shows that every increase in the length of education taken by women reduces their opportunity to work by 0.9378. The regional minimum wage variable has significant positive results, which means that the larger the regional minimum wage, the bigger their chances for employment. The odd ratio indicates that each increase in the regional minimum wage would increase women's involvement in employment by 1.4137. An interesting result appears in the variable number of children. The result of the data processing is a significant negative coefficient. This means that the more children they have, the higher is chances for the women to decide not to work. Every increase in the number of children will reduce their likeliness to work by 0.9560, as indicated by the odd ratio value. The result of the data processing on the variable area of residence is significant and positive, indicating that women residing in urban areas are more involved in work. The odd ratio value in the variable of area of residence means that married women who live in urban areas have the opportunity to decide to work by 1.1194.

Table 4

Classification Estimation

Classified + if predicted Pr(D) >= 0.5

True D defined as Y1= 0

Sensitivity

Pr( +| D)

3.69%

Specificity

97.79%

Positive Predictive Value

Pr( D| +)

50.29%

Negative Predictive Value

Pr(~D| -)

62.58%

False + rate for true ~D

Pr( +| ~D)

2.21%

False - rate for true D

Pr( -| D)

96.31%

False + rate for classified +

Pr( ~D| +)

49.71%

False - rate for classified -

Pr( D| -)

37.42%

Correctly Classified

62.24%

Source: own calculation

In order to obtain a statistical summary of the estimated results from the logistic regression model, classification estimates are carried out. The above table presents the results of the classification. The number of observations that have been classified correctly according to the actual classification from the data is 62.24%. This value shows the extent to which the model succeeded in predicting the correct classification and gives an idea of the accuracy of the model. The result of the sensitivity or true positive rate is 3.69%, and the specificity value is 97.79%.

patriarchal gender labor іndonesian woman

Women's multiple role

Data processing shows that the education level of the female labor force does not incline their involvement in work. The number of married women's involved in work, which is lower than that of unmarried ones, indicates the influence from their husbands. The husbands, being heads of the family, believe they have the right to decide where their wives should work and spend their time; they can even instruct their wives to refrain from working and play their domestic roles instead. The results of the study indicate the prevailing gender inequality in households, in which women are positioned below men. Even if there are cases where women are allowed to engage in work, they have to play the dual role in domestic and public spheres. In addition, employers frequently discriminate against married women in the belief that they are less productive and reliable due to their domestic burdens (Florian, 2018). As a result, women find it difficult to find work that suits their conditions and needs (Kizilova & Mosakova, 2019). Meanwhile, men have more opportunities for better career options and higher wages than those of women (Yang, 2020).

However, the recurring problem that afflict working women is their obligation to keep a delicate balance between their domestic and workplace responsibilities. As a consequence, married women tend to have lower labour force participation rates than unmarried women. Alternatively, married women become self-employed (Eib & Siegert, 2019). This phenomenon is caused by various factors, such as the traditional roles of women as housewives and the difficulty of finding suitable work with flexible working hours (Lari, 2022). This assumption finds its solid ground in a strong cultural belief that women are in charge of domestic affairs. In addition to this deeply-rooted role, married working women have to deal with their husbands when it comes to matters like this. Patriarchal culture stands in the way, preventing (married) women from landing their desired jobs.

The regional minimum wage variable shows positive results with a significant p-value. This indicates that an increase in the regional minimum wage increases the likeliness of the female labor force to get more involved in work. It is only human that people work for the sole purpose of earning wages and improving their families' welfare, so the prospect of getting better wages keeps them motivated to engage in the job market. However, working women frequently have to struggle against wage inequality. This phenomenon occurs when men get a higher wage rate (Yang, 2020) on the assumption that they are the main breadwinners for the family (Jara Diaz & Candia Riquelme, 2017). This phenomenon is also explained in social role theory, where men are the main actors who make ends meet. However, based on data from the Ministry of Women's Empowerment and Child Protection, ten percent of Indonesian women are the backbones of the family. It is understandable that they aspire for equal wages and treatment.

The number of children in this study represents the dependents in the family. Logically, the number of children in the family will increase the expenses for their education and healthcare. In view of the above reasons, families with a larger number of children will try to get better income. However, results of the study show that the greater number of children in the family will decrease women's likeliness to work. This finding contradicts the research of Bearak et al. (2021) in which women who have children will be more motivated to work. The results of this study make sense because, when women have more children, they will dedicate more time to play their role as a mother. The greater number of children in the family increases the childcare costs, should a mother wants to keep working. However, if there is a discrepancy between income and childcare costs, then women will choose not to work in order to focus more on their motherhood.

Analysis on area of residence have significant positive results. This indicates that women from urban areas have a higher likeliness to get involved in work. In the case of Indonesia, there is an educational disparity between urban and rural area residents. The link is that urban residents are better than rural residents in terms of education and skills. Better educational facilities result in better human resources, thus changing their mindsets. Urban women who are more open-minded frequently think about getting themselves involved in work and become economically productive. People who live in rural areas, on the other hand, still live by their orthodox cultural guidance that are far from liberating (Undurraga & Gunnarsson, 2021). In addition, investment also affects the available jobs. Urban areas are more developed as they have better human resources and more public facilities. Hence, investors tend to invest more in urban areas, making more labor absorption in those areas.

Cultural stereotype

Patriarchal culture refers to family values or habits that glorify men's power and authority. These values and tenets put women at the mercy of men, and their basic rights are frequently denied (Roscigno, 2019; Sabharwal, 2023). Seen from the spectacle of radical feminists, patriarchal culture is the main limiting factor which constrains women's self-actualization and personal development. Ironically, women's scope of work and involvement in the economy reveal grim facts about the patriarchal culture (Jensen, 2021; Pandey, 2022; Bastian et al., 2019). When viewed from a national perspective, gender inequality in public sphere has created retardation in the development of a country (Altuzarra, 2021) where the status of working men is always higher than women in terms of position and income (Klemparskyi et al., 2022).

Indonesian women's lives are overshadowed by cultural values that they accept and adopt as a guidance for their lives both at home and within their surroundings (Budiati, 2010). Even in aggregate, cultural values can reduce women's labor force participation although women's employment opportunities are increasing (Undurraga & Gunnarsson, 2021). Javanese women's culture is interlinked with patriarchal values and gender inequality. In this cultural setting, women's departure to work is considered taboo among rural people because generally they are supposed to stay at home, doing household chores and care for their young. At home, women find their lives surrounded by impenetrable patriarchal culture (Puspitasari et al., 2022). This is especially true among Javanese women who are socially expected to be good at three main roles of women: macak (grooming themselves and constantly taking care of their looks), manak (being able to conceive and have children), and masak (preparing food for the family). These expressions showcase the dominant patriarchal culture in which men are perceived and treated as powerful figures and women are always docile and faithful to their husbands. Similar cultural values binding Javanese women are narrated by Nyi Hartati in her book Serat Centhini. It is the metaphor of the five digits or “KiasLima Jari Tangan.” A woman's thumb symbolizes a wife's obedience; a woman must follow her man's whims. The forefinger is symbolical of her commitment to stay true to her husband's wishes and directions. The middle finger symbolizes her commitment to maintain her husband's dignity. The ring finger is the symbol of woman's duty to approach her husband with her fair countenance. The little symbolizes her impeccable skill to do things, including the duties of pleasing her husband. The above explanation clearly shows that a Javanese wife's life is forever dictated by her husband's will and wishes, including those that affect her decisions in life. According to the United Nations, the existing forms of sex-based discrimination related to rights, obligations, and attitudes are referred to as gender inequality. Such discrimination has made it hard for the governments to define men and women's rights and obligations and their respective importance.

The diversity of factors that influence women's tendency to work or not is intricately connected to cultural values which create and perpetuate gender inequality. Within the family, women must abide by their husbands' decisions. In the context of national economy, involvement of the labor force in productivity greatly influences the economy, especially in this era of demographic bonuses in which of productive people outnumbers the aging people and this creates a window of opportunity. However, many women in Indonesia are still shackled by cultural values preventing them from developing themselves and finding expressions to their creativity. One among many agendas that can be established to reduce gender inequality is getting women involved in participatory decision makings. This gives women ample room to maneuver and encourages them to find self-actualisation in public. Within the scope of employment, enforced labor rights can provide women with wages and career path opportunities that are equal to men.

Conclusion and suggestions

Data analysis, backed up by actual situation in Indonesia shows that inequality in work and a patriarchal culture do exist, and this raises criticism. The relevance of discussing inequality for women in the economy is that women who are given space and freedom can increase their lab our force participation. Female labor force participation can increase a country's productivity, which will positively impact its progress through contributions to production, economic business, and employment, especially in this era of demographic bonuses. Such participation can provide a multiplier effect on the consumption curve thanks to women's ability to purchase goods and services which in turn will set the economic wheels in motion. Another positive impact form women empowerment is the improved quality in domestic life. Women with open mind and wider horizons have better awareness of health and nutrition, and they will raise competitive future generations.

The community can preserve Javanese culture and local values, pass on the virtues to the next generation as to maintain national and cultural identity. Nevertheless, Javanese must advance and modernize their way of thinking, especially when it is about the role and position of women. In the modern era, women are expected to be involved in self-development and actualization in the public sphere. Providing space and freedom for them has long-lasting implications, one of which is better human resources.

However, this study only focuses on women and their immediate surroundings. Future prospective researchers may add variables that are closely related to women, such as husband's education level. New research variables pertaining to husbands will certainly bring more decisive results, considering women's lives are frequently dictated by the opinion of the household heads. The higher the husband's education level, the better the decisions are made in the family. Two assumptions can be made from the addition of husband's education as a variable. First, as the husband has a higher level of education, he will get more decent wage that enables him to provide for his family, and the wife does not need to work. Second, higher education can modernize his way of thinking. He, in turn, will give his wife the freedom to engage in work other economic activities.

References

1. Abraham, A.Y., Ohemeng, F.N.A., & Ohemeng, W. (2017). Female labour force participation: Evidence from Ghana. International Journal of Social Economics, 44(11), 1489-1505.

2. Adeosun, O.T., & Owolabi, K.E. (2021). Gender inequality: determinants and outcomes in Nigeria. Journal of Business and Socio-Economic Development, 1(2), 165-181.

3. Ahmed, I., & Brasted, H. (2021). Recognition and Dissent: Constitutional Design and Religious Conflict in Pakistan. Journal of Contemporary Asia, 51(2),351-367.

4. Akhtar, R., Masud, M. M., Jafrin, N., & Shahabudin, S. M. (2023). Economic growth, gender inequality, openness of trade, and female labour force participation: a nonlinear ARDL approach. Economic Change and Restructuring, 0123456789.

5. Alloatti, M.N. (2019). The challenge of measuring women's economic empowerment: A critical analysis on the importance of subjective measurement and context. Advances in Gender Research, 28, 41-59.

6. Altuzarra, A. (2021). Is Gender Inequality a Barrier to Economic Growth? A Panel Data Analysis of Developing Countries.

7. Assaad, R., Hendy, R., Lassassi, M., & Yassin, S. (2020). Explaining the MENA paradox: Rising educational attainment yet stagnant female labor force participation. Demographic Research, 43(September), 817-850.

8. Assaad, R., Krafft, C. G., & Selwaness, I. (2017). The Impact of Early Marriage on Women's Employment in the Middle East and North Africa. GLO Discussion Paper, 66(May 2019).

9. Awaworyi Churchill, S., Nuhu, A. S., & Lopez, K. (2019). Persistence of gender inequality: the role of ethnic divisions. Applied Economics,51(8),781-796.

10. Bai, W., Yue, Z., & Zhou, T. (2023). Jumping to male-dominated occupations: A novel way to reduce the gender wage gap for Chinese women. Heliyon, 9(3), e14198.

11. Bastian, B.L., Metcalfe, B.D., & Zali, M.R. (2019). Gender Inequality: Entrepreneurship Development in the MENA Region. 1-26.

12. Baublyte, G., Korhonen, J., D'Amato, D., & Toppinen, A. (2019). “Being one of the boys”: perspectives from female forest industry leaders on gender diversity and the future of Nordic forest-based bioeconomy. Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research, 34(6), 521528.

13. Bearak, J.M., Popinchalk, A., Burke, K.L., & Anjur-Dietrich, S. (2021). Does the impact of motherhood on women's employment and wages differ for women who plan their transition into motherhood? Demography, 55(4), 1301-1325.

14. Belasen, A., & Angiello, J. (2018). The Important Role of Women in Social Entrepreneurship. Women and Leadership, 1-126.

15. Berniell, I., Berniell, L., Mata, D. de la, Edo, M., & Marchionni, M. (2021). Gender gaps in labor informality: The motherhood effect. Journal of Development Economics, 159(June 2019), 102599.

16. Bloom, D.E., Canning, D., Fink, G., & Finlay, J. E. (2009). Fertility, female labor force participation, and the demographic dividend. Journal of Economic Growth, 14(2), 79101.

17. Braunstein, E., Bouhia, R., & Seguino, S. (2020). Social reproduction, gender equality and economic growth. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 44(1), 129-156.

18. Budiati, A C. (2010). Aktualisasi Diri Perempuan Dalam Sistem Budaya Jawa (Persepsi Perempuan terhadap Nilai-nilai Budaya Jawa dalam Mengaktualisasikan Diri). Pamator, 3(1), 51-59.

19. Cuberes, D., & Teignier, M. (2014). Gender inequality and economic growth: a critical review. Journal of International Development, 26(2), 260-276.

20. Dawood, T.C., Pratama, H., Masbar, R., & Effendi, R. (2019). Does financial inclusion alleviate household poverty? Empirical evidence from Indonesia. Economics and Sociology, 12(2), 235-252.

21. De Cieri, H., Holmes, B., Abbott, J., & Pettit, T. (2005). Achievements and challenges for work/life balance strategies in Australian organizations. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 16 (1), 90-103.

22. De Hoyos, R.E. (2011). Female labor participation and occupation decisions in post-nafta mexico. In Research in Labor Economics (Vol. 33). Emerald Group Publishing Ltd.

23. Dorio, J.M., Bryant, R.H., & Allen, T.D. (2008). Work-Related Outcomes of the Work-Family Interface” Why Organizations Should Care Work-family conflict an d work-related.

24. Eib, C., & Siegert, S. (2019). Is Female Entrepreneurship Only Empowering for Single Women? Evidence from France and Germany. Social Science, 5(128).

25. England, P., Bearak, J., Budig, M. J., & Hodges, M. J. (2016). Do Highly Paid, Highly Skilled Women Experience the Largest Motherhood Penalty? American Sociological Review, 51(6), 1161-1189.

26. Ennaji, M. (2016). Women, gender, and politics in Morocco. Social Sciences, 5(4).

27. Florian, S.M. (2018). Motherhood and Employment Among Whites, Hispanics, and Blacks: A Life Course Approach Sandra. Physiology & Behavior, 176, 139-148.

28. Motherhood Ford, M., & Gillan, M. (2017). In search of a living wage in Southeast Asia. Employee Relations, 39(6), 903-914.

29. Gavriluta, N., Grecu, S.P., & Chiriac, H.C. (2022). Sustainability and Employability in the Time of COVID-19. Youth, Education and Entrepreneurship in EU Countries. Sustainability (Switzerland), 14(3).

30. Hasan, R., & Molato, R. (2019). Wages over the course of structural transformation: Evidence from India. Asian Development Review, 36(2), 131-158.

31. Iqbal, A., Hassan, S., Mahmood, H., & Tanveer, M. (2022). Gender equality, education, economic growth and religious tensions nexus in developing countries: A spatial analysis approach. Heliyon, 5(11).

32. Ismail, R., Farhadi, M., & Wye, C.K. (2017). Occupational Segregation and Gender Wage Differentials: Evidence from Malaysia. Asian Economic Journal, 31(4), 381-401.

33. Jara Diaz, S., & Candia Riquelme, D. (2017). Uso Del Tiempo En Chile: Analisis Preliminar Y Posibilidades De Modelacion. 18 Congreso Chileno de Ingenieria de Transporte, 21, 103-116.

34. Jensen, R. (2021). Getting Radical: Feminism, Patriarchy, and the Sexual-Exploitation Industries. Dignity: A Journal of Analysis of Exploitation and Violence, 6(2).

35. Johansson, K., Andersson, E., Johansson, M., & Lidestav, G. (2019). The Discursive Resistance of Men to Gender-equality Interventions: Negotiating “Unjustness” and “Unnecessity” in Swedish Forestry. Men and Masculinities, 22(2), 177-196.

36. Kizilova, K., & Mosakova, E.A. (2019). The birth rate in BRICS countries under the gender inequality in the labor market. RUDN Journal of Sociology, 19(4), 630-638.

37. Klemparskyi, M.M., Pavlichenko, H.V, Ye,R., Mohilevskyi, L.V, & Burniagina, Y.M. (2022). Gender inequality in the labor market of Ukraine Challenges for the future. Work Organisation, Labor &Globalisation,16(2),140-157.

38. Korabik, K., & Warner, M. (2013). The impact of co-workers on work-to-family enrichment and organizational outcomes. Expanding the Boundaries of Work-Family Research: A Vision for the Future, 1, 254-278.

39. Korotayev, A.V., Issaev, L.M., & Shishkina, A.R. (2015). Female Labor Force Participation Rate, Islam, and Arab Culture in Cross-Cultural Perspective. Cross-Cultural Research, 49(1), 3-19.

40. Lari, N. (2022). Toward marriage sustainability: Impacts of delayed marriages in Qatar. Cogent Social Sciences, 5(1).

41. Lari, N., Awadalla, A., Al-Ansari, M., & Elmaghraby, E. (2022). Determinants of female labor force participation: implications for policy in Qatar. Cogent Social Sciences, 5(1).

42. Larraz, B., Pavia, J.M., & Vila, L.E. (2019). Beyond the gender pay gap. In Convergencia (Vol. 26, Issue 81).

43. Larson, P.D. (2020). Corruption, gender inequality and logistics performance. International Journal of Logistics Management, 31(2), 381-397.

44. Majbouri, M. (2020). Fertility and the puzzle of female employment in the Middle East and North Africa. Economics of Transition and Institutional Change, 28(2), 225-244.

45. Marois, G., Zhelenkova, E., & Ali, B. (2022). Labor Force Projections in India Until 2060 and Implications for the Demographic Dividend. Social Indicators Research, 164(1), 477-497.

46. Medina-Hernandez, E.J., Fernandez-Gomez, M.J., & Barrera-Mellado, I. (2021). Analysis of time use surveys using co-statis: A multiway data analysis of gender inequalities in time use in colombia. Sustain ability (Switzerland),13(23).

47. Minasyan, A., Zenker, J., Klasen, S., & Vollmer, S. (2019). Educational gender gaps and economic growth: A systematic review and meta-regression analysis. World Development,122,199-217.

48. Moon, Z.K., & Hasan, M.M. (2022). Childcare center for work efficiency of employed parents: perception analysis for business prospects. South Asian Journal of Marketing.

49. Munir, K., & Kanwal, A. (2020). Impact of educational and gender inequality on income and income inequality in South Asian countries. International Journal of Social Economics, 47(8), 1043-1062.

50. Pandey, N. (2022). Feminist Narrativization of Patriarchy in Swosthani Vrata Katha. Journal of Tikapur Multiple Campus, 5(June), 152-167.

51. Podder, S. (2018). Gender Wage Inequality and Economic Recession. Journal of Quantitative Economics, 16(1), 155-171.

52. Poduval, J., & Poduval, M. (2009). Working mothers: How much working, How much mothers, and where is the womanhood. Mens Sana Monographs, 7(1), 63-79.

53. Pratomo, D. S. (2014). Does minimum wage affect hours worked of paid employment in Indonesia? International Journal of Social Economics, 41(5), 362-379.

54. Puspitasari, D., Pudjibudojo, J. K., & Hartanti, H. (2022). Decision-making on divorce for Javanese women in Indonesia. International Journal of Environmental, Sustainability, and Social Science, 3(3), 702-712.

55. Rendall, M. (2013). Structural Change in Developing Countries: Has it Decreased Gender Inequality? World Development, 45, 1-16.

56. Roscigno, V.J. (2019). Discrimination, Sexual Harassment, and the Impact of Workplace Power. Socius, 5.

57. Rudakov, V., Kiryushina, M., Figueiredo, H., & Teixeira, P.N. (2022). Early career gender wage gaps among university graduates in Russia. International Journal of Manpower, ahead-of (ahead-of-print).

58. Sabharwal, M. (2023). Rising Gender Inequities in India: 1(1), 59-74.

59. Senadza, B. (2012). Education inequality in Ghana: Gender and spatial dimensions. Journal of Economic Studies, 39(6), 724-739.

60. Shoham, A., & Lee, S.M. (2018). The Causal Impact of Grammatical Gender Marking on Gender Wage Inequality and Country Income Inequality. Business and Society, 57(6), 1216-1251

61. Undurraga, R., & Gunnarsson, J. (2021). The fragility of women's work trajectories in Chile. Social Sciences, 10(5). 48

62. Ville, A., Wong, G., Aceituno, A.J., Downing, A., Karambiri, M., & Brockhaus, M. (2023). What is the `problem' of gender inequality represented to be in the Swedish forest sector? Environmental Science and Policy,140 (October 2022), 46-55.

63. Yang, J. (2020). Women in china moving forward: Progress, challenges and reflections. Social Inclusion, 8(2), 23-35.

Размещено на Allbest.Ru

...

Подобные документы

  • Global Feminist Revolution. Women’s Emancipation Movement. Feminism in International Relations and Discrimination. Gender discrimination. Women in the History of International Relations. Women Officials in the contemporary International Relations.

    реферат [22,6 K], добавлен 21.11.2012

  • The concept and sex, and especially his studies in psychology and sociology at the present stage. The history of the study of the concepts of masculinity and femininity. Gender issues in Russian society. Gender identity and the role of women in America.

    дипломная работа [73,0 K], добавлен 11.11.2013

  • Study the opinion of elderly people and young people about youth culture. Subculture as a group of people with the same interests and views on life. Passion for today's youth to heavy music, computers, dance parties and special styles of clothing.

    презентация [654,6 K], добавлен 28.10.2014

  • Understanding of social stratification and social inequality. Scientific conceptions of stratification of the society. An aggregated socio-economic status. Stratification and types of stratification profile. Social stratification of modern society.

    реферат [26,9 K], добавлен 05.01.2009

  • The need for human society in the social security. Guarantee of social security in old age, in case of an illness full or partial disability, loss of the supporter, and also in other cases provided by the law. Role of social provision in social work.

    презентация [824,4 K], добавлен 16.10.2013

  • Problems in school and with parents. Friendship and love. Education as a great figure in our society. The structure of employed young people in Russia. Taking drugs and smoking as the first serious and actual problem. Informal movements or subcultures.

    контрольная работа [178,7 K], добавлен 31.08.2014

  • The concept, definition, typology, characteristics of social institute. The functions of social institution: overt and latent. The main institution of society: structural elements. Social institutions of policy, economy, science and education, religion.

    курсовая работа [22,2 K], добавлен 21.04.2014

  • The study of human populations. Demographic prognoses. The contemplation about future social developments. The population increase. Life expectancy. The international migration. The return migration of highly skilled workers to their home countries.

    реферат [20,6 K], добавлен 24.07.2014

  • American marriage pattern, its types, statistics and trends among different social groups and ages. The reasons of marriage and divorce and analyzing the statistics of divorce and it’s impact on people. The position of children in American family.

    курсовая работа [48,3 K], добавлен 23.08.2013

  • The concept of public: from ancient times to era of Web 2.0. Global public communication. "Charlie Hebdo" case. Transition of public from on-line to off-line. Case study: from blog to political party. "M5S Public": features and mechanisms of transition.

    дипломная работа [2,7 M], добавлен 23.10.2016

  • The nature and content of the concept of "migration". The main causes and consequences of migration processes in the modern world. Countries to which most people are emigrating from around the world. TThe conditions for obtaining the status of "migrant".

    презентация [4,8 M], добавлен 22.03.2015

  • The essence of social research communities and their development and functioning. Basic social theory of the XIX century. The main idea of Spencer. The index measuring inequality in income distribution Pareto. The principle of social action for Weber.

    реферат [32,5 K], добавлен 09.12.2008

  • Гендерная социализация как проблема глобального общества. Современное общество Беларуси и проблема его гендерной социализации. Меры по реализации гендерной политики. Содержание понятия "Gender". Общественное доверие как показатель социализации личности.

    контрольная работа [36,7 K], добавлен 18.07.2013

  • Four common social classes. Karl Marx's social theory of class. Analysis the nature of class relations. The conflict as the key driving force of history and the main determinant of social trajectories. Today’s social classes. Postindustrial societies.

    презентация [718,4 K], добавлен 05.04.2014

  • Overpopulation, pollution, Global Warming, Stupidity, Obesity, Habitat Destruction, Species Extinction, Religion. The influence of unemployment in America on the economy. The interaction of society with other societies, the emergence of global problems.

    реферат [21,1 K], добавлен 19.04.2013

  • Women and work: type of employment, labor for pregnant women in modern days. Reasons for oppression. Laws that helped women. Feminist model of female education. University of Texas compared to Cambridge. Women's health in the Victorian period and today.

    курсовая работа [43,1 K], добавлен 15.08.2013

  • The Commission on the Status of Women. World Summit on Sustainable Development. Problems of Education for Women. Education’s Effects on Reproductive Choice. The interaction between the region’s economic structure and its conservative culture in the USA.

    реферат [26,4 K], добавлен 16.12.2011

  • Study of lexical and morphological differences of the women’s and men’s language; grammatical forms of verbs according to the sex of the speaker. Peculiarities of women’s and men’s language and the linguistic behavior of men and women across languages.

    дипломная работа [73,0 K], добавлен 28.01.2014

  • The themes, analysis and solutions raised by feminists with reference to Australian work, and outline a Marxist analysis of violence against women. The importance of violence against women as a political issue. The emergence of women as sexual beings.

    реферат [91,4 K], добавлен 20.06.2010

  • The situation of women affected by armed conflict and political violence. The complexity of the human rights in them. Influence of gender element in the destruction of the family and society as a result of hostilities. Analysis of the Rwandan Genocide.

    реферат [10,9 K], добавлен 03.09.2015

Работы в архивах красиво оформлены согласно требованиям ВУЗов и содержат рисунки, диаграммы, формулы и т.д.
PPT, PPTX и PDF-файлы представлены только в архивах.
Рекомендуем скачать работу.